What’s with the prioritization of “essential” workers?
-
@jon-nyc said in What’s with the prioritization of “essential” workers?:
I’m talking about vaccine prioritization only.
There seems to be this idea that there’s a thing called “essentialness” with the property such that the more of it you have the higher up you are in the queue.
I think that needs to be defended, and would be hard to defend if anyone tried.
I haven’t even see anyone try.
I have seen a lot of pieces arguing who has more “essentialness” than whom. But none arguing why vaccine prioritization should be based on it.
As a practical matter I think they sent most to hospitals for distribution just to get started. Most hospitals are doing only employees now and by tier. Covid unit, Covid patients first and then possibility of Covid exposure second.
The logistics in doing this is amazing. First you create Health record, then you schedule, then you administer, then you schedule the second and all the while you have to keep track of all this stuf including supply. Oh and all your vaccinating locations need to be certified by the state and maybe the immunization registry.
-
A number of my customers have managed to designate themselves as 'essential'. If you knew them, you'd laugh. I know I did.
Proud supporter of Plan 2525. Everything you think, do and say will be in the pill you took today.
-
As far as I'm aware, all several thousand employees of the company I work for are considered essential.
-
@doctor-phibes said in What’s with the prioritization of “essential” workers?:
Maybe the argument would be that "essential workers" are obliged to continue working, and therefore put themselves at higher risk of infection?
It's sounds like bollocks to me.
I think that’s the intuition behind it, but note that’s just a justification for why the (political) decision was made.
-
"Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08
The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.
-
-
Education is extremely important.
-
2/3 of Howard University Hospital workers won’t take the vaccine. Apparently our racist past is the cause of distrust.
Ergo no one should get the vaccine. Which is the way we felt about it until one week after the election anyway.
Don’t trust the vaccine was the mantra and now we have people all over the map on it. I guess that was Trumps fault too.
-
Sweet. Let’s hope most of these essential workers don’t trust it so we can get to the people at greater risk and save more lives.
-
-
Every single US state is being advised to consider ethnic minorities as critical groups for vaccination with HALF prioritizing black and Hispanic residents over white...
As a result, half of the nation's states have outlined plans that now prioritize black, Hispanic and indigenous residents over white people in some way, as the vaccine rollout begins.
According to our analysis, 25 states have committed to a focus on racial and ethnic communities as they decided which groups should be prioritized in receiving a coronavirus vaccine dose.
These include New Mexico, where collaboration with Native Americans is being prioritized; California, which has committed to ensuring black and Hispanic people have greater access to the vaccine; and Oregon, where health officials have said that ethnic minorities with have 'equitable access' to the shot.
Some states have made even more specific plans to prioritize communities of color, with 12 states specifically mentioning efforts to partner with healthcare providers in areas with a large minority population to reach 'diverse populations', according to Kaiser Family Foundation.
The CDC has also issued guidance on its Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) that uses 15 U.S. census variables to help local officials identify communities that may need support.
It is being used in states such as Michigan where minority status and language spoken could be taken into consideration when deciding how high a priority you are for receiving a vaccine.
Maine, in particular, has developed a 'Racial/Ethnic Minority COVID-19 Vaccination Plan' in an attempt to give a preference to groups that 'have experienced rates of disease that far exceed their representation in the population as a whole'.
Just a reminder....
"Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08
The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.
-
@george-k said in What’s with the prioritization of “essential” workers?:
The CDC has also issued guidance on its Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) that uses 15 U.S. census variables to help local officials identify communities that may need support.
I hope you guys remembered to identify as vulnerable person when you completed your census form.
-
I was a little surprised that Trump’s plan did this too.
-
In all fairness, it seems that minorities are at a greater health risk for the disease and it is also spreading faster through their communities.
As for the politicians, I understand the optics, but continuity and a functioning government are vital to beating this disease (too bad we haven’t had a functioning government in decades...) and 1000 vaccines going to officials is s drop in the bucket. If it’s causing a delay, it can be measured by the hour, not by days or weeks...
-
That's true LD, but two points:
-
It's worse for men than women. You don't even hear discussion about that in terms of prioritization, it's not eve brought up and knocked down.
-
DO we really know if race is an actual risk factor? Or is it a correlate of true risk factors? IOW they're more likely to live in dense areas, take more risks, not be able to work from home, etc.
I'm guessing its the latter. In which case prioritizing based on actual risk factors should 'make them whole'.
-
-
@jon-nyc said in What’s with the prioritization of “essential” workers?:
I was a little surprised that Trump’s plan did this too.
This is an important point because even the states that haven't announced a desire to discriminate based on race and ethnicity will do so anyway unless they modify Trump's plan.
