Is it safe?
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 13:40 last edited by
One of D3's friends tested positive for SARS-CoV-2. I assume it was a nasal swab. She's had no contact with him since the test (or for months before, for that matter).
Now, it's been two weeks and he wants to celebrate a mutual friend's birthday by renting a movie theater room. He says that it's big enough that they could remain "socially distant."
Thoughts?
My gut says, "Nah." I don't trust him.
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 13:48 last edited by
If I didn't see the report stating he was positive for the antibodies, no.
Trust your gut.
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 13:51 last edited by
Risk/benefit analysis. The movie party loses.
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 13:53 last edited by Jolly
As a thread drift...
The market is starting to winnow out the crappy tests, at least in the clinical labs subject to CLIA 88. The problem is the tiny doctor office labs, where the people performing the test are not labortorians. The mainline labs are still subject to method comparison, precision, accuracy, etc. The docs plop it on the counter and call it good.
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 14:52 last edited by
Two points:
I agree with Jolly and Mik. If she hasn't seen him for months, I would not think there would be urgent on her part to see him right now, especially will everything going on.
Second - University of Illinois has got approval for a saliva test they developed. Appears to be much easier then the "sticking the stick up your nose test"
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 14:55 last edited by
No way.
-
Two points:
I agree with Jolly and Mik. If she hasn't seen him for months, I would not think there would be urgent on her part to see him right now, especially will everything going on.
Second - University of Illinois has got approval for a saliva test they developed. Appears to be much easier then the "sticking the stick up your nose test"
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 15:23 last edited by Jolly@taiwan_girl said in Is it safe?:
Two points:
I agree with Jolly and Mik. If she hasn't seen him for months, I would not think there would be urgent on her part to see him right now, especially will everything going on.
Second - University of Illinois has got approval for a saliva test they developed. Appears to be much easier then the "sticking the stick up your nose test"
It's approved under the Emergency Act. I've seen some absolutely shitty tests approved under that act, then later yanked from the market.
Don't fall for the bally-hoo.
-
@taiwan_girl said in Is it safe?:
Two points:
I agree with Jolly and Mik. If she hasn't seen him for months, I would not think there would be urgent on her part to see him right now, especially will everything going on.
Second - University of Illinois has got approval for a saliva test they developed. Appears to be much easier then the "sticking the stick up your nose test"
It's approved under the Emergency Act. I've seen some absolutely shitty tests approved under that act, then later yanked from the market.
Don't fall for the bally-hoo.
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 15:24 last edited by@Jolly Good point.
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 19:21 last edited by
@George-K said in Is it safe?:
Thoughts?
My gut says, "Nah." I don't trustAsymptomatic? Or did he develop symptoms? What was the reason for taking the test in the first place? Has he had a followup test to make sure that he's clear?
How does your daughter feel? She's an adult...
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 21:12 last edited by
I would not trust the friend either.
My kids are adults as well. But they live with me and I fully support them. If I told them not to go to a party, I fully expect them to not go to a party.
-
@George-K said in Is it safe?:
Thoughts?
My gut says, "Nah." I don't trustAsymptomatic? Or did he develop symptoms? What was the reason for taking the test in the first place? Has he had a followup test to make sure that he's clear?
How does your daughter feel? She's an adult...
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 21:29 last edited by George K@LuFins-Dad said in Is it safe?:
Asymptomatic? Or did he develop symptoms? What was the reason for taking the test in the first place?
Sore throat and a fever.
Has he had a followup test to make sure that he's clear?
Nope
How does your daughter feel? She's an adult...
"I don’t even want to touch anything that he touches. If we were outside, I wouldn’t care much, but nothing indoors...Yeah I’m staying away...Well at least I know I’m not overthinking...He tested positive on 8/6."
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 22:11 last edited by
A friend had a child go away to camp. 300 tested positive for Covid. 12 had symptoms, none for more than a day or two.
This is what is going through young people’s minds.
-
@LuFins-Dad said in Is it safe?:
Asymptomatic? Or did he develop symptoms? What was the reason for taking the test in the first place?
Sore throat and a fever.
Has he had a followup test to make sure that he's clear?
Nope
How does your daughter feel? She's an adult...
"I don’t even want to touch anything that he touches. If we were outside, I wouldn’t care much, but nothing indoors...Yeah I’m staying away...Well at least I know I’m not overthinking...He tested positive on 8/6."
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 22:54 last edited by@George-K said in Is it safe?:
@LuFins-Dad said in Is it safe?:
Asymptomatic? Or did he develop symptoms? What was the reason for taking the test in the first place?
Sore throat and a fever.
Has he had a followup test to make sure that he's clear?
Nope
How does your daughter feel? She's an adult...
"I don’t even want to touch anything that he touches. If we were outside, I wouldn’t care much, but nothing indoors...Yeah I’m staying away...Well at least I know I’m not overthinking...He tested positive on 8/6."
My concern wouldn't be him. It would be everybody... Chances are good that at least one of the other party-goers was exposed to him since he was originally infected or was exposed to whoever infected him originally...
-
@George-K said in Is it safe?:
@LuFins-Dad said in Is it safe?:
Asymptomatic? Or did he develop symptoms? What was the reason for taking the test in the first place?
Sore throat and a fever.
Has he had a followup test to make sure that he's clear?
Nope
How does your daughter feel? She's an adult...
"I don’t even want to touch anything that he touches. If we were outside, I wouldn’t care much, but nothing indoors...Yeah I’m staying away...Well at least I know I’m not overthinking...He tested positive on 8/6."
My concern wouldn't be him. It would be everybody... Chances are good that at least one of the other party-goers was exposed to him since he was originally infected or was exposed to whoever infected him originally...
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 22:56 last edited by@LuFins-Dad like his wife....
-
wrote on 20 Aug 2020, 22:58 last edited by
Of the set of all humans who have told me they're doing shit like that in a "totally safe" way, the subset of those humans who have actually kept their word continues to be null.
