Is a longer train more likely to derail?
-
tl;dr
Yes.
Replacing two 50-car trains with one 100-car train raises the aggregate odds of derailment by 11 percent, the study concluded—even accounting for an overall decrease in the number of trains running. A 200-car train would have a 24 percent increase compared with four 50-car trains, according to the study team’s calculations.
-
Simple statistics say yes, even if there’s not a cumulative effect (which there is).
If every car has a percentage chance of derailing, let’s call it X, then a 5 car train will have a 5X chance of derailing. A 50 car train would have a 50X chance…
But more than that, each train car adds mass to the overall train, which acts as a force multiplier for every car you add.
-
Simple statistics say yes, even if there’s not a cumulative effect (which there is).
If every car has a percentage chance of derailing, let’s call it X, then a 5 car train will have a 5X chance of derailing. A 50 car train would have a 50X chance…
But more than that, each train car adds mass to the overall train, which acts as a force multiplier for every car you add.
@LuFins-Dad said in Is a longer train more likely to derail?:
Simple statistics say yes, even if there’s not a cumulative effect (which there is).
If every car has a percentage chance of derailing, let’s call it X, then a 5 car train will have a 5X chance of derailing. A 50 car train would have a 50X chance…
But more than that, each train car adds mass to the overall train, which acts as a force multiplier for every car you add.
Hmmm....
Not sure if that works. If you take 5 INDIVIDUAL cars, then, of course, they would have 5 times the chance of derailing of a single car.
But, it's not that simple.
There are other forces - pull on the couplers? - that might, might, have a stabilizing effect preventing the derailment of any individual car in a long train.
Does increased mass increase the risk of derailment? Once again, one might argue that an increased mass has other unrecognized effects. Is a heavier car more stable on the rails?
-
@LuFins-Dad said in Is a longer train more likely to derail?:
Simple statistics say yes, even if there’s not a cumulative effect (which there is).
If every car has a percentage chance of derailing, let’s call it X, then a 5 car train will have a 5X chance of derailing. A 50 car train would have a 50X chance…
But more than that, each train car adds mass to the overall train, which acts as a force multiplier for every car you add.
Hmmm....
Not sure if that works. If you take 5 INDIVIDUAL cars, then, of course, they would have 5 times the chance of derailing of a single car.
But, it's not that simple.
There are other forces - pull on the couplers? - that might, might, have a stabilizing effect preventing the derailment of any individual car in a long train.
Does increased mass increase the risk of derailment? Once again, one might argue that an increased mass has other unrecognized effects. Is a heavier car more stable on the rails?
@George-K said in Is a longer train more likely to derail?:
@LuFins-Dad said in Is a longer train more likely to derail?:
Simple statistics say yes, even if there’s not a cumulative effect (which there is).
If every car has a percentage chance of derailing, let’s call it X, then a 5 car train will have a 5X chance of derailing. A 50 car train would have a 50X chance…
But more than that, each train car adds mass to the overall train, which acts as a force multiplier for every car you add.
Hmmm....
Not sure if that works. If you take 5 INDIVIDUAL cars, then, of course, they would have 5 times the chance of derailing of a single car.
But, it's not that simple.
There are other forces - pull on the couplers? - that might, might, have a stabilizing effect preventing the derailment of any individual car in a long train.
Does increased mass increase the risk of derailment? Once again, one might argue that an increased mass has other unrecognized effects. Is a heavier car more stable on the rails?
The mass of the individual cars stays the same. It’s the momentum that is massively increased.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login