Puzzle time - odd run of heads

jon-nyc

On average, how many flips of a coin does it take to get a run of an odd number of heads, preceded and followed by tails?

Klaus

You mean something like THT or THHTHHHT right? And at the end of the run there's always a single T, right?

Klaus

:::
You didn't specify that the solution must be analytic, so...

Just for the heck of it, I thought this might be a good excuse to play around with WebPPL.

This is the distribution and expected value I got.

The model I used was this. You can just copy&paste it to http://webppl.org/ and play around with it, if you want to get an impression of what probabilistic programming is.

var oddrun = function() {
  var fluntil = function() {
    flip(.5) ? fluntil() + 1 : 1
  }
  var flodd = function() {
    if (flip(.5)) {
      return { success : false , l : 1} 
    } else { 
      var r = flodd();
      return { success : !(r.success), l : r.l+1 } ;
    }
  }
  var run = function() {
    var r = flodd()
    return r.success ? r.l : r.l + run()
  };
  var l = fluntil()
  return l + run()
}
var dist = Infer(
  {method: 'enumerate', maxExecutions: 50000},
  oddrun);

viz.auto(dist);
display("Expected Value:")
display(expectation(dist))

:::

jon-nyc

@klaus

I haven’t solved it yet but that seems too low.

The only sequences with less than 5 flips satisfying our conditions are:

THT
TTHT
HTHT

Unless I’m calculating wrong probability of getting any of these three is 1/4

Klaus

Oh right, I think there was a missing plus sign in my model, which I've now fixed.

This is what I get now.

:::

This looks right to me. The probability of THT is 1/8. The probability of TTHT or HTHT is 1/16, with a combined probability of 1/8.

My take for an analytic solution would be to count how many "winning" sequences of length n there are (let's call this q(n)) and then compute the limit of the sum of all i*q(i) / (2^i)
(for i = 1 to infinity) to get the expected value. Obviously, q(1)=0, q(2) = 0, q(3) = 1 and q(4) = 2. From the distribution diagram above I infer q(5) = 4 and q(6) = 7.

This looks suspiciously similar to the Fibonacci sequence minus one.

:::

Klaus

:::

That's the limit of the sum of all i*(Fib(i)-1) / (2^i). The main insight is that the number of "winning" sequences of length i is Fib(i)-1.

I don't really have an argument why it needs to be Fib(i)-1 (except the "abductive reasoning" rationale above), but I'm pretty confident that it is correct.
:::

jon-nyc

I got the same answer both by grinding it out and with a cute solution that I’ll share later.

Klaus

With a small change in the task it should be possible to construct it in such a way that the average number of flips is infinite.

The New Coffee Room

Puzzle time - odd run of heads