Electric car game changer
-
It seems to me like a lot is going to need to change for this to be achievable.
Google indicates a car battery capacity is roughly 50kWh, so to charge one in 5 minutes is going to need a charger capable of delivering 50 x 12 = 600 kW. For a battery voltage of 400V (again from Google), this correlates to 1500 Amps, which is a stupidly high current.
Or am I missing something obvious?
@doctor-phibes said in Electric car game changer:
It seems to me like a lot is going to need to change for this to be achievable.
Google indicates a car battery capacity is roughly 50kWh, so to charge one in 5 minutes is going to need a charger capable of delivering 50 x 12 = 600 kW. For a battery voltage of 400V (again from Google), this correlates to 1500 Amps, which is a stupidly high current.
Or am I missing something obvious?
From the article...
"StoreDot is aiming to deliver 100 miles of charge to a car battery in five minutes in 2025. "
100 miles in 5 minutes sounds like 1/3 of the total capacity of the batteries.
So maybe 500 amps. Not that much of a stretch.
7 years ago I was charging 4 x 5,000 mAH Lithium Polymer batteries to full capacity in 5 minutes.
3D RC helicopters routinely pull 200 amps while flying.
-
Hey @Doctor-Phibes, how fat a piece of copper cable would be needed to transfer 1500 Amps, for, say 1 meter of distance between the charging station and the car?
I tried to use an online wire gauge calculator to figure out how the wire gauge needed to transfer 1500 Amps and the calculator says that number is "out of range."
I try to imagine a bundle of 10x the sort of power grid cable that feeds 200 Amps to a typical residence and it does not seem that bad, maybe a cable bundle that's 10cm across? :man-shrugging:
-
Not sure about specifics - all the tables I found didn't go as high as 1500A. Typically, in the work I do the maximum prospective short circuit current of a mains installation is considered to be about 1500A - i.e. that's the most you'll get out of it under some horrendous fault, in a transient condition. And we're going to be doing that in normal operation, under steady state conditions?
Hey, at least the safety folks will have job security.
It's always felt to me that a hundred years from now they'll be laughing at our ridiculous intention to swap out gasoline for batteries in the hope of reducing pollution.
Hydrogen's the way to go.
-
.... says the guy who regularly broke the laws of physics.
-
Enables <15 minute fast charge (0 to 80%) by eliminating lithium diffusion bottleneck in anode host material.
-
Enables <15 minute fast charge (0 to 80%) by eliminating lithium diffusion bottleneck in anode host material.
@copper said in Electric car game changer:
Enables <15 minute fast charge (0 to 80%) by eliminating lithium diffusion bottleneck in anode host material.
Since that's 3 times the charge time of the other one, this is already completely obsolete, and it hasn't even been released!
-
It seems to me like a lot is going to need to change for this to be achievable.
Google indicates a car battery capacity is roughly 50kWh, so to charge one in 5 minutes is going to need a charger capable of delivering 50 x 12 = 600 kW. For a battery voltage of 400V (again from Google), this correlates to 1500 Amps, which is a stupidly high current.
Or am I missing something obvious?
@doctor-phibes said in Electric car game changer:
It seems to me like a lot is going to need to change for this to be achievable.
Google indicates a car battery capacity is roughly 50kWh, so to charge one in 5 minutes is going to need a charger capable of delivering 50 x 12 = 600 kW. For a battery voltage of 400V (again from Google), this correlates to 1500 Amps, which is a stupidly high current.
Or am I missing something obvious?
That's what I thought as well.
The most powerful charging stations over here charge with 200KW. They are extremely expensive and require enormous cooled cables.
Also, the influence on the stability of the overall power grid, bot locally and nationally, would presumably be quite significant if thousands of cars would suddenly begin charging at 600KW.
Finally, I wonder what a realistic cost for a kwh of energy would be from one of those super duper charging stations. From what I read, a fair non-subsidized price for a kwh at a high power charging station would be >1$ per kwh, so we can all guess how much that would be with a 600KW charging station. It is in any case orders of magnitude more expensive than gasoline.
I also wonder what the influence of the super-fast charging on the life time of the battery is. Usually, batteries are not happy about such things.
-
Dead end technology. You think oil isn’t renewable? Compare that to Lithium! We’re digging a hole faster and faster.
-
A related story:
https://techxplore.com/news/2021-01-inexpensive-battery-rapidly-electric-vehicles.html
Range anxiety, the fear of running out of power before being able to recharge an electric vehicle, may be a thing of the past, according to a team of Penn State engineers who are looking at lithium iron phosphate batteries that have a range of 250 miles with the ability to charge in 10 minutes.
"We developed a pretty clever battery for mass-market electric vehicles with cost parity with combustion engine vehicles," said Chao-Yang Wang, William E. Diefenderfer Chair of mechanical engineering, professor of chemical engineering and professor of materials science and engineering, and director of the Electrochemical Engine Center at Penn State. "There is no more range anxiety and this battery is affordable."
The researchers also say that the battery should be good for 2 million miles in its lifetime.
They report today in Nature Energy that the key to long-life and rapid recharging is the battery's ability to quickly heat up to 140 degrees Fahrenheit, for charge and discharge, and then cool down when the battery is not working.
"The very fast charge allows us to downsize the battery without incurring range anxiety," said Wang.
The battery uses a self-heating approach previously developed in Wang's center. The self-heating battery uses a thin nickel foil with one end attached to the negative terminal and the other extending outside the cell to create a third terminal. Once electrons flow it rapidly heats up the nickel foil through resistance heating and warm the inside of the battery. Once the battery's internal temperature is 140 degrees F, the switch opens and the battery is ready for rapid charge or discharge.
Wang's team modeled this battery using existing technologies and innovative approaches. They suggest that using this self-heating method, they can use low-cost materials for the battery's cathode and anode and a safe, low-voltage electrolyte. The cathode is thermally stable, lithium iron phosphate, which does not contain any of the expensive and critical materials like cobalt. The anode is made of very large particle graphite, a safe, light and inexpensive material.
Because of the self-heating, the researchers said they do not have to worry about uneven deposition of lithium on the anode, which can cause lithium spikes that are dangerous.
"This battery has reduced weight, volume and cost," said Wang. "I am very happy that we finally found a battery that will benefit the mainstream consumer mass market."
According to Wang, these smaller batteries can produce a large amount of power upon heating—40 kilowatt hours and 300 kilowatts of power. An electric vehicle with this battery could go from zero to 60 miles per hour in 3 seconds and would drive like a Porsche, he said.
-
"Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08
The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.
-
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
@89th said in Electric car game changer:
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
Couple of weeks it appears.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-26/biden-drives-his-corvette-for-episode-of-jay-leno-s-garageOf course, I am sure it was a "closed course" etc But, it wouldn't be a smart idea to have the President of the US driving around in public. LOL
Kind of like the questions I asked about the queen also would apply to the president - last time they actually handled money? Last time they waited in line? etc
-
You'd think we'd have heard something more about the '5 minute re-charge' - it's been about 20 months. I'm a little surprised they haven't got it down to like 20 minutes at this point - it's not long until 2023, after all.
My prediction - Star Citizen will be finished before this is in place.
-
@89th said in Electric car game changer:
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
Couple of weeks it appears.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-26/biden-drives-his-corvette-for-episode-of-jay-leno-s-garageOf course, I am sure it was a "closed course" etc But, it wouldn't be a smart idea to have the President of the US driving around in public. LOL
Kind of like the questions I asked about the queen also would apply to the president - last time they actually handled money? Last time they waited in line? etc
@taiwan_girl said in Electric car game changer:
@89th said in Electric car game changer:
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
Couple of weeks it appears.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-26/biden-drives-his-corvette-for-episode-of-jay-leno-s-garageOf course, I am sure it was a "closed course" etc But, it wouldn't be a smart idea to have the President of the US driving around in public. LOL
Kind of like the questions I asked about the queen also would apply to the president - last time they actually handled money? Last time they waited in line? etc
[boomer]
He drove the economy into a recession, drove gas prices up and drove us all crazy so I'd say he's doing quite a lot.Hey-ohhhhhhhh.
[/boomer] -
@89th said in Electric car game changer:
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
Couple of weeks it appears.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-26/biden-drives-his-corvette-for-episode-of-jay-leno-s-garageOf course, I am sure it was a "closed course" etc But, it wouldn't be a smart idea to have the President of the US driving around in public. LOL
Kind of like the questions I asked about the queen also would apply to the president - last time they actually handled money? Last time they waited in line? etc
@taiwan_girl said in Electric car game changer:
@89th said in Electric car game changer:
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
Couple of weeks it appears.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-26/biden-drives-his-corvette-for-episode-of-jay-leno-s-garageOf course, I am sure it was a "closed course" etc But, it wouldn't be a smart idea to have the President of the US driving around in public. LOL
Kind of like the questions I asked about the queen also would apply to the president - last time they actually handled money? Last time they waited in line? etc
I can see Joe more behind the wheel of a Trans Am T-Top, but a Vette guy would be a close second…
-
@taiwan_girl said in Electric car game changer:
@89th said in Electric car game changer:
Serious question, when was the last time you think he drove anywhere? I bet it's been at least 5 or 10 years.
Couple of weeks it appears.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-26/biden-drives-his-corvette-for-episode-of-jay-leno-s-garageOf course, I am sure it was a "closed course" etc But, it wouldn't be a smart idea to have the President of the US driving around in public. LOL
Kind of like the questions I asked about the queen also would apply to the president - last time they actually handled money? Last time they waited in line? etc
I can see Joe more behind the wheel of a Trans Am T-Top, but a Vette guy would be a close second…
@LuFins-Dad said in Electric car game changer:
I can see Joe more behind the wheel of a Trans Am T-Top
And there it is: A nice slow pitch, right over home plate....
