The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread
-
Speaker Johnson seems to have forgotten that we no longer have a "Department of Defense". We now have a "Department of War". War Departments make war.
@kluurs said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
Speaker Johnson seems to have forgotten that we no longer have a "Department of Defense". We now have a "Department of War". War Departments make war.
According to Secretary of Limited Operations Hegseth it’s not a war.
-
@jon-nyc said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
In the past 24 hours, Trump is insisting he must have a say in who is appointed to replace Khamenei and govern Iran.
In the past few hours, Trump is now calling for Iran’s unconditional surrender.
Yes, the US is in a state of war with Iran.
No other way to describe it.
@Renauda said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
@jon-nyc said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
In the past 24 hours, Trump is insisting he must have a say in who is appointed to replace Khamenei and govern Iran.
Sick BURN by Iran's deputy foreign minister:
"Trump is asking for change in the leadership of Iran and he says he has to have a voice on that while he cannot even appoint the Mayor of New York"
-
One thing is really interesting to me, and that is the difference in military effectiveness of the US in Iran versus Russia in Ukraine. They're quite backward. Aside from missiles and drones it is still WWII style warfare.
"You cannot subsidize irresponsibility and expect people to become more responsible." — Thomas Sowell
-
Big mistake if we even consider a ground game. Sure assassinate their leaders, and bomb the crap out of their revolutionary guard and missile sites, all opinions about that aside, you could leave the operation relatively quickly and see how the Persian dust settles?
My guess of what will happen? The story in a few years will be written like this:
Following Khamenei’s death in 2026, Iran descended into a prolonged, violent power struggle, transforming from a centralized state into a fractured country with rival governments, armed militias, and deep instability. A decade of civil war ensued, characterized by foreign intervention, economic collapse, and a humanitarian crisis, leaving it split between eastern and western factions.
Political Division: The country is divided between the UN-supported government and forces loyal to Khamenei's people, specifically their revolutionary guard. Attempts to form a unified government have largely failed to end the conflict.
Failed State Conditions: Iran has experienced severe instability, with armed militias controlling various regions, leading to a rise in human trafficking, unlawful detention, and, for a period, control by extremist groups like ISIS.
Economic Collapse: Despite having the largest oil reserves in Asia, Iran’s oil production has been frequently halted by blockades, causing extreme economic damage and infrastructure failure.
Humanitarian Crisis: The chaos has led to the displacement of citizens, a lack of basic services, and, in some cases, the discovery of mass graves.
While open conflict has reduced in recent years, the nation remains fragile, with a stalled political process and ongoing struggles over control of resources, particularly oil, in the eastern "oil crescent".
-
One thing is really interesting to me, and that is the difference in military effectiveness of the US in Iran versus Russia in Ukraine. They're quite backward. Aside from missiles and drones it is still WWII style warfare.
@Mik said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
One thing is really interesting to me, and that is the difference in military effectiveness of the US in Iran versus Russia in Ukraine. They're quite backward. Aside from missiles and drones it is still WWII style warfare.
The first few months of the Russo-Ukraine war resembled WWII a war in of manoeuvre. Since then it has been more like WWI trench warfare characterized by artillery barrages and occasional infantry advances against fortified defensive positions that result in very limited territorial gains and heavy casualties on the battlefield.
The only real manoeuvres appear to be in the sky with the attack drones and missiles.
-
@Mik said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
Yeah, I don't know how one could torture the words otherwise.
They could try to sell it as a Special Military Operation.
Doubt if anyone with half a brain would buy it.
@Renauda said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
@Mik said in The Iran War (was Nuclear Program) thread:
Yeah, I don't know how one could torture the words otherwise.
They could try to sell it as a Special Military Operation.
Doubt if anyone with half a brain would buy it.
Well ... we are talking about the MAGA folks after all.
