Woke is here to stay
-
-
Where I could I looked at the trend of the topic not the search term, for that reason. Some weren’t available as topics, so I showed the search term.
-
I don't actually know what "trend" means or how it relates to search volumes. But I'll stand by my main point that you'd have to provide a convincing argument that the quantity of "woke" terms in new writing isn't a good way to measure how entrenched the ideas are in the culture.
-
An example - homophobia as a topic vs a search term.
DON’T let them eat cake.
- RFK Jr -
@jon-nyc said in Woke is here to stay:
An example - homophobia as a topic vs a search term.
I'll tell you what, you choose a metric now, and if Trump wins, we'll revisit it in a couple years to see if your prediction of a spike in that measure has become reality.
-
Just kidding, you'll be in a concentration camp if Trump wins, so we won't be able to settle that, unless the camp emissaries can bargain with Trump's fascist regime for internet access, provided to the sole victor in the pit fighting arenas. I expect you to win, and I expect you to use your prize of five minutes online time to settle this particular score on TNCR.
-
-
How about using equity?
-
Different meanings. Equity stake.
-
@Horace. These probably all correlate pretty well. A resurgence of wokeness in the culture would probably be visible in most of these. Some can get goosed by world events independent of Trump or US politics. Eg ‘settler colonialism’ peaked in late 23.
Hopefully we will never know what a second Trump term would have brought.
DON’T let them eat cake.
- RFK Jr -
@jon-nyc said in Woke is here to stay:
@Horace. These probably all correlate pretty well. A resurgence of wokeness in the culture would probably be visible in most of these.
I'll stand by my point that you'd have to provide a convincing argument that the quantity of "woke" terms in new writing isn't a good way to measure how entrenched the ideas are in the culture. Since the measures you presented tell a different story, one that more confirms your bias that Trump is the main catalyst of woke, we'd have to make some attempt at understanding why your story is different than the numbers presented in the piece I linked to. I don't expect that conversation here, I'm just noting that I'm happy with the metrics from the piece I linked to, assuming they are accurate, since they are transparently meaningful. Your google metrics are a black box to me, of unknown significance.
-
Measuring words is a good way, but as I said before, there’s a difference between words produced by the general population and those of, say, Ivy League anthropology departments or the staff at Deadspin.
A detailed historical record of all social media posts would be ideal. Measuring word frequency which is objective, yet with a general audience rather than press or academic studies.
DON’T let them eat cake.
- RFK Jr -
@jon-nyc said in Woke is here to stay:
Measuring words is a good way, but as I said before, there’s a difference is words produced by the general population and those of, say, Ivy League anthropology departments or the staff at Deadspin.
A detailed historical record of all social media posts would be ideal. Measuring word frequency which is objective, yet with a general audience rather than press or academic studies.
of the three charts in the piece, only one is focused on academic papers. One is a from polls of what people believe about a certain woke idea, and one is about "print media" and its word frequencies.
-
Again, print media and academics are their own subcultures.
-
I have no doubt that a Trump election will make twitter and facebook and reddit explode with references to white supremacy. What that establishes is that many people are primed to make that specific complaint in response to a certain election result. These people will not have been on the fence about white supremacy before the election, then swayed towards it after. These are indoctrinated people who will or will not be motivated to complain publicly, based on the results of the election.
-
So we are in complete agreement that a Trump election would bring on a surge in wokeness by your favored metric.
DON’T let them eat cake.
- RFK Jr -
Which is my problem with them. He’s not trying to measure the broader culture.
-
If your point about Trump causing wokeness boils down to a claim that Trump being elected will cause people to complain about Trump being elected, and those complaints will often have a woke angle, then we are in complete agreement. I consider that a nearly meaningless point, but if you think it's meaningful then you can continue to run with it.
-
No you’re straw manning my position again.
DON’T let them eat cake.
- RFK Jr
