The Ten Commandments Required
-
After being educated by Advisory Opinions….
The case isn’t as much of a slam dunk as I thought because the praying football coach case did strike down the old ‘Lemon test’ (named for a court case) that had invalidated similar laws in the past.
Both Sarah and David think Louisiana loses in the end though. And if they win a similar law replacing the Ten Commandments with the five pillars of Islam would also be allowed.
Go to about 41:30 in the most recent AO if you’re interested in details.
-
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Content in the realization that I’m the only one here that can read that.
-
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Content in the realization that I’m the only one here that can read that.
@bachophile Ok, question : Do we really know what the vowels are in ancient Hebrew?
-
Vowels are a later addition
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hebrew_diacritics
I can’t say if Biblical Hebrew sounded the same, but the text is readily apparent and understandable
-
MN — Following Louisiana's recent addition of the Ten Commandments to school classrooms, sources close to George Floyd Elementary reported that a teacher who keeps BLM and Pride flags prominently displayed in her classroom demanded that the government "keep all religion out of our schools."
Eyewitnesses in the classroom said indigenous history and genderqueer theory teacher Ladasha Sullet was "absolutely flabbergasted" to hear about Louisiana's new mandate and immediately started shouting about how the government's job is to "keep any and all religions out of the classroom, not shove them down children's throats."
"That's a total violation of the separation of the church and state!" exclaimed Sullet, momentarily pausing her lecture on the femmeboy branch of genderfluidity to make sure her fourth-grade students properly understood her position on the issue. "There is absolutely no call for any sort of religion to be represented or displayed in a public school classroom — ever! Stop preaching at us!"
Students reported that Sullet continued her rant about not letting religion into public schools for the rest of the class period, then dismissed class after carefully adjusting her Pride flag and genuflecting before a small portrait of George Floyd she keeps as a shrine on her desk.
At publishing time, Sullet had instituted daily readings from Mao's Little Red Book for her students after teaching them how dangerous and destructive it would be for any teacher to read students religious books like the Bible.
-
https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/article-807712
Three Jewish families are among a group of nine Louisiana families with children in public schools who have filed a suit in federal court challenging a new state law that requires the Ten Commandments be displayed in all public school classrooms.
The lawsuit — filed on the families’ behalf by Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, the American Civil Liberties Union and the Freedom from Religion Foundation — argues that the law enacted last week violates the First Amendment.
Specifically, the complaint says that the language of the law “Approves and Prescribes One Particular Version of the Ten Commandments, to Which Many People Do Not Subscribe,” violating the Constitution’s prohibitions on establishing an official religion and prohibiting free exercise of religion.
-
https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/article-807712
Three Jewish families are among a group of nine Louisiana families with children in public schools who have filed a suit in federal court challenging a new state law that requires the Ten Commandments be displayed in all public school classrooms.
The lawsuit — filed on the families’ behalf by Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, the American Civil Liberties Union and the Freedom from Religion Foundation — argues that the law enacted last week violates the First Amendment.
Specifically, the complaint says that the language of the law “Approves and Prescribes One Particular Version of the Ten Commandments, to Which Many People Do Not Subscribe,” violating the Constitution’s prohibitions on establishing an official religion and prohibiting free exercise of religion.
Here’s another piece on the pending lawsuit:
The legal action points out that a central pillar of the new law – the claim that there is a long tradition linking the Ten Commandments to public education in the US – is based on a fabrication. HB71 quotes James Madison, the fourth president, as saying: “We have staked the whole future of our new nation … upon the capacity of each of ourselves to govern ourselves according to the moral principles of the 10 Commandments.”
That quote is fictitious; it is to be found in none of Madison’s writings or speeches. It appears to have been drawn from a conspiracy theory popularized by the late rightwing talk show host Rush Limbaugh.
Full article:
https://amp.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/jun/24/louisiana-ten-commandments-schools-lawsuit
-
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Even Catholics and Protestants have (slightly) different versions of the commandments.
I think the main differences are in which ones they choose to ignore.
-
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Even Catholics and Protestants have (slightly) different versions of the commandments.
I think the main differences are in which ones they choose to ignore.
@Doctor-Phibes said in The Ten Commandments Required:
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Even Catholics and Protestants have (slightly) different versions of the commandments.
I think the main differences are in which ones they choose to ignore.
Well, at least they have some guidelines, many are trying to live by them and they are aware of their failures.
-
@Doctor-Phibes said in The Ten Commandments Required:
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Even Catholics and Protestants have (slightly) different versions of the commandments.
I think the main differences are in which ones they choose to ignore.
Well, at least they have some guidelines, many are trying to live by them and they are aware of their failures.
@Jolly said in The Ten Commandments Required:
@Doctor-Phibes said in The Ten Commandments Required:
@jon-nyc said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Even Catholics and Protestants have (slightly) different versions of the commandments.
I think the main differences are in which ones they choose to ignore.
Well, at least they have some guidelines, many are trying to live by them and they are aware of their failures.
'Twas but a joke.
-
Not a great joke, but it is consistent.
Anytime someone says Catholic, he says - Catholics are not perfect because they don't obey all the rules.
It's not much of a joke, but I guess some think the irony is hilarious.
People fail, then get up and try again, over and over, it is kind of like slapstick I guess.
-
Not a great joke, but it is consistent.
Anytime someone says Catholic, he says - Catholics are not perfect because they don't obey all the rules.
It's not much of a joke, but I guess some think the irony is hilarious.
People fail, then get up and try again, over and over, it is kind of like slapstick I guess.
@Copper said in The Ten Commandments Required:
Not a great joke, but it is consistent.
Anytime someone says Catholic, he says - Catholics are not perfect because they don't obey all the rules.
It's not much of a joke, but I guess some think the irony is hilarious.
People fail, then get up and try again, over and over, it is kind of like slapstick I guess.
My apologies if my little joke didn't meet your high standards at humour. Next time I'll try writing the same single word response over and over. That's always an absolute hoot.
