Conservatives have a Millennial problem
-
I put it very simply. Where there exists social value in party affiliation, and no demonstrable sacrifice, party affiliation is all but a foregone conclusion. How does that change? Demonstrable sacrifice. People need to feel like the policies they support with their kind, compassionate, and socially advantageous votes, are actually costing them. The party of compassion does not actually feel they make any sacrifice for their votes. This even comes through in that Twitter thread, where a common belief is wealth redistribution. Millenials who can't afford homes, are not thinking that that redistribution will be from themselves, towards others. They believe it will be from others, towards themselves.
-
I put it very simply. Where there exists social value in party affiliation, and no demonstrable sacrifice, party affiliation is all but a foregone conclusion. How does that change? Demonstrable sacrifice. People need to feel like the policies they support with their kind, compassionate, and socially advantageous votes, are actually costing them. The party of compassion does not actually feel they make any sacrifice for their votes. This even comes through in that Twitter thread, where a common belief is wealth redistribution. Millenials who can't afford homes, are not thinking that that redistribution will be from themselves, towards others. They believe it will be from others, towards themselves.
@Horace said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
This even comes through in that Twitter thread, where a common belief is wealth redistribution. Millenials who can't afford homes, are not thinking that that redistribution will be from themselves, towards others. They believe it will be from others, towards themselves.
How do we explain the relatively poor, relatively uneducated white folk who voted for Trump in such large numbers?
You don't think they actually believed he cared about them, do you?
-
@Horace said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
This even comes through in that Twitter thread, where a common belief is wealth redistribution. Millenials who can't afford homes, are not thinking that that redistribution will be from themselves, towards others. They believe it will be from others, towards themselves.
How do we explain the relatively poor, relatively uneducated white folk who voted for Trump in such large numbers?
You don't think they actually believed he cared about them, do you?
@Doctor-Phibes said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
@Horace said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
This even comes through in that Twitter thread, where a common belief is wealth redistribution. Millenials who can't afford homes, are not thinking that that redistribution will be from themselves, towards others. They believe it will be from others, towards themselves.
How do we explain the relatively poor, relatively uneducated white folk who voted for Trump in such large numbers?
You don't think they actually believed he cared about them, do you?
You don't have any idea why they voted for him? Trump rode the culture wars to the white house. He was their mouthpiece in those wars.
The twitter thread mentions a couple times that the millenials in question, are solidly on the other side of those wars.
Education is extremely important.
-
I'd vote for Bill Maher in a heartbeat. You'd at least know what you were getting. It'd be a nice change of pace and you can't make any cogent argument that'd he'd be worse.
-
@Doctor-Phibes said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
@Horace said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
This even comes through in that Twitter thread, where a common belief is wealth redistribution. Millenials who can't afford homes, are not thinking that that redistribution will be from themselves, towards others. They believe it will be from others, towards themselves.
How do we explain the relatively poor, relatively uneducated white folk who voted for Trump in such large numbers?
You don't think they actually believed he cared about them, do you?
You don't have any idea why they voted for him? Trump rode the culture wars to the white house. He was their mouthpiece in those wars.
The twitter thread mentions a couple times that the millenials in question, are solidly on the other side of those wars.
@Horace said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
You don't think they actually believed he cared about them, do you?
I think they did, or many of them did.
You don't have any idea why they voted for him? Trump rode the culture wars to the white house. He was their mouthpiece in those wars.
Yes. Trump is/was a master salesman. He studied his market, probably for many years, and then went after them. And did it impeccably.
Hopefully, that will only work once.
-
You can coherently consider a politician to be a product which does what you vote for it to do. The emotions the product feels while they do those things, or its alleged motivations for doing those things, is irrelevant. Which is a good thing, because politicians, to a person, do a lot of pretending about their feelings and motivations. Some pretend better than others. Add to that the psychological soup of whether they buy their own nonsense, and can seem and feel completely earnest as they pretend, and you get to a point where a rational person stops caring so much about whether a politician "cares".
-
Owen Jones' article at The Guardian on millennials not getting more conservative as they age:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/04/right-millennials-vote-snowflakes-conservative
It speaks to the phenomenon pertaining to American and British millennials. It's central argument seems to blame it on the modem right wingers' spitefulness in rhetoric and in policy.
-
Owen Jones' article at The Guardian on millennials not getting more conservative as they age:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/04/right-millennials-vote-snowflakes-conservative
It speaks to the phenomenon pertaining to American and British millennials. It's central argument seems to blame it on the modem right wingers' spitefulness in rhetoric and in policy.
@Axtremus said in Conservatives have a Millennial problem:
Owen Jones' article at The Guardian on millennials not getting more conservative as they age:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jan/04/right-millennials-vote-snowflakes-conservative
It speaks to the phenomenon pertaining to American and British millennials. It's central argument seems to blame it on the modem right wingers' spitefulness in rhetoric and in policy.
A fine example of a tribal polemic where all virtue lies with the author's political tribe, and all character flaw lies with the other tribe. These things are not difficult to write.
The fact will remain that people will vote for whichever party they believe benefits them the most. No millenial to whom that piece resonates, believes they could safely express sympathy for conservative politics, without damaging their social and even professional relationships.
