Bottles VS Cans

[Doctor Phibes]

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@LuFins-Dad said in Bottles VS Cans:

No, beer is best from a glass, and I agree with Mik about Draft first…

Sounds like it's time for a double-blind controlled, peer-reviewed study.

I suspect that the results would be similar to digital vs analog sound recordings. One would be able to tell the difference, but I doubt that one would be able to discern which is which.

I can't tell the difference between bottled beer and canned beer, but draft real cask ale from a good pub is almost a different drink entirely.

[89th]

Cans are always better but I agree that sometimes you just need to drink it out of a bottle.

Now let’s talk about coke. Plastic bottle is the worst. Cans are better. McD’s fountain is better than that. But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

[Jolly]

Sadly, I've bought Cokes in glass bottles for a nickel. The small ones. Ice cold. Then looked at the bottom of the bottle, to see where it came from.

Sadly? Yes, because none of the kids today will be able to do that.

[George K]

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

[89th]

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

Azucar, baby!

[Jolly]

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

Mexican Cokes are made with cane sugar. Most of the taste difference is the formulation.

I mentioned the small bottles. IIRC, those were 7 ounces. Much like a little Miller, the small Cokes are meant to be consumed straight from the bottle and the smaller volume means it's usually still cold by the time you take the last swig.

[Jolly]

BTW, I don't care for Pepsi, except for the throwback version. The difference in Pepsi made with cane sugar is even more than the differences between Cokes.

[Catseye3]

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

Now let’s talk about coke. Plastic bottle is the worst.

The Coke in them ain't got much to say for itself either.

[LuFins Dad]

@Jolly said in Bottles VS Cans:

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

Mexican Cokes are made with cane sugar. Most of the taste difference is the formulation.

I mentioned the small bottles. IIRC, those were 7 ounces. Much like a little Miller, the small Cokes are meant to be consumed straight from the bottle and the smaller volume means it's usually still cold by the time you take the last swig.

The Cane Sugar thing appears to be in doubt… https://healthland.time.com/2010/10/28/study-hey-hipsters-mexican-coke-might-be-a-myth/

I’ll say this, there is something to the way the bottle fits the hand, the cold glass, the little vapor when you pop the top off… It’s probably mostly nostalgia, but yeah, there’s something to the bottle…

[mark]

If they start putting single malt into cans, I am done.

[Doctor Phibes]

@LuFins-Dad said in Bottles VS Cans:

@Jolly said in Bottles VS Cans:

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

Mexican Cokes are made with cane sugar. Most of the taste difference is the formulation.

I mentioned the small bottles. IIRC, those were 7 ounces. Much like a little Miller, the small Cokes are meant to be consumed straight from the bottle and the smaller volume means it's usually still cold by the time you take the last swig.

The Cane Sugar thing appears to be in doubt… https://healthland.time.com/2010/10/28/study-hey-hipsters-mexican-coke-might-be-a-myth/

I’ll say this, there is something to the way the bottle fits the hand, the cold glass, the little vapor when you pop the top off… It’s probably mostly nostalgia, but yeah, there’s something to the bottle…

TBH, I couldn't tell much difference when I tried a Mexican Coke.

Then again, it's only freaking Coke....'Ah yes, I can sense the notes of plastic that enhance the underlying tone of phosporic acid and caramel colouring....'

[Mik]

I lost interest when they took cocaine out of it.

[Jolly]

@Doctor-Phibes said in Bottles VS Cans:

@LuFins-Dad said in Bottles VS Cans:

@Jolly said in Bottles VS Cans:

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

Mexican Cokes are made with cane sugar. Most of the taste difference is the formulation.

I mentioned the small bottles. IIRC, those were 7 ounces. Much like a little Miller, the small Cokes are meant to be consumed straight from the bottle and the smaller volume means it's usually still cold by the time you take the last swig.

The Cane Sugar thing appears to be in doubt… https://healthland.time.com/2010/10/28/study-hey-hipsters-mexican-coke-might-be-a-myth/

I’ll say this, there is something to the way the bottle fits the hand, the cold glass, the little vapor when you pop the top off… It’s probably mostly nostalgia, but yeah, there’s something to the bottle…

TBH, I couldn't tell much difference when I tried a Mexican Coke.

Then again, it's only freaking Coke....'Ah yes, I can sense the notes of plastic that enhance the underlying tone of phosporic acid and caramel colouring....'

Ferchrissakes, you drink warm beer. You couldn't tell the difference if they put Lysol in the bottle...

[Doctor Phibes]

@Jolly said in Bottles VS Cans:

@Doctor-Phibes said in Bottles VS Cans:

@LuFins-Dad said in Bottles VS Cans:

@Jolly said in Bottles VS Cans:

@George-K said in Bottles VS Cans:

@89th said in Bottles VS Cans:

But glass bottles from Mexico are top seed.

I'm not sure the difference in taste with Mexican Coke Coca-Cola is attributable to the bottle, but rather the formulation.

Mexican Cokes are made with cane sugar. Most of the taste difference is the formulation.

I mentioned the small bottles. IIRC, those were 7 ounces. Much like a little Miller, the small Cokes are meant to be consumed straight from the bottle and the smaller volume means it's usually still cold by the time you take the last swig.

The Cane Sugar thing appears to be in doubt… https://healthland.time.com/2010/10/28/study-hey-hipsters-mexican-coke-might-be-a-myth/

I’ll say this, there is something to the way the bottle fits the hand, the cold glass, the little vapor when you pop the top off… It’s probably mostly nostalgia, but yeah, there’s something to the bottle…

TBH, I couldn't tell much difference when I tried a Mexican Coke.

Then again, it's only freaking Coke....'Ah yes, I can sense the notes of plastic that enhance the underlying tone of phosporic acid and caramel colouring....'

Ferchrissakes, you drink warm beer. You couldn't tell the difference if they put Lysol in the bottle...

Brace yourself, the Bud Light jokes are coming....

[taiwan_girl]

@Copper said:

Beer tastes better from a bottle.

In this order:

1. Coors Golden Banquet beer, The 1936 Stubby Bottle
2. Piels Real Draft Beer 7 oz Bottles - Pony Barrel Bottle
3. Schlitz pop-top, real gusto

End of discussion

Scratch off #3 from the list.

Last week, Pabst Brewing Company announced its plan to discontinue Schlitz, a once-beloved brand known as “the beer that made Milwaukee famous.” Pabst cited rising storage and shipping costs as the reasons for the decision to shut down the historic brand. Wisconsin Brewing Co. — which has brewed Pabst products in the past — will brew the last batch of Schlitz on May 23, Milwaukee Magazine reports.

Schlitz launched in Milwaukee, Wis., in 1849 as the flagship beer of Joseph Schlitz Brewing Company, which reigned as the country’s largest brewery until Anheuser-Busch ousted it from that spot in the late 1950s. A series of production shortcuts and questionable ad campaigns for the American-style lager initiated the brand’s fall from grace in the second half of the century. Schlitz closed its home brewery in 1981, and Stroh Brewery Company purchased it the following year. Pabst then scooped it up in 1999.