Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Users
  • Groups
Skins
  • Light
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Quartz
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor

  • Default (No Skin)
  • No Skin
Collapse

The New Coffee Room

  1. TNCR
  2. General Discussion
  3. Trump to unveil healthcare plan

Trump to unveil healthcare plan

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Discussion
111 Posts 10 Posters 1.2k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • X xenon
    23 Oct 2020, 22:06

    @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

    Do you pay more out of pocket for the best surgeon or ortho? Should you?

    Why wouldn't you pay more for higher quality?

    You do that for everything else, food, clothing, shelter, transportation, toys and games.

    Have you ever explicitly paid more or less for specific physicians?

    C Offline
    C Offline
    Copper
    wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 22:46 last edited by
    #61

    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

    @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

    Do you pay more out of pocket for the best surgeon or ortho? Should you?

    Why wouldn't you pay more for higher quality?

    You do that for everything else, food, clothing, shelter, transportation, toys and games.

    Have you ever explicitly paid more or less for specific physicians?

    Yes, a lot more.

    I subscribed to a concierge plan up until I moved last year. I liked the doctor, I had been seeing him for years. When he switched to this plan I followed him.

    You can read about it here: https://www.mdvip.com/

    1 Reply Last reply
    • L Loki
      23 Oct 2020, 22:42

      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

      I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

      This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

      Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

      Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

      Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

      You can get the answers from him directly.

      X Offline
      X Offline
      xenon
      wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 22:53 last edited by xenon
      #62

      @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

      I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

      This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

      Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

      Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

      Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

      You can get the answers from him directly.

      You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

      I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

      My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

      They are not. That’s a market failure.

      L C 2 Replies Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:02
      • X xenon
        23 Oct 2020, 22:18

        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

        S few networks. I hire the best and negotiate.

        I'm trying to understand. My insurance has always covered physicians - I lived in SF so had access to to pretty expensive, nationally high ranked systems.

        Why would you go over and above your insurance?

        L Offline
        L Offline
        Larry
        wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 22:59 last edited by
        #63

        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

        S few networks. I hire the best and negotiate.

        I'm trying to understand. My insurance has always covered physicians - I lived in SF so had access to to pretty expensive, nationally high ranked systems.

        Why would you go over and above your insurance?

        You didn't understand a damned word I said.

        1 Reply Last reply
        • X xenon
          23 Oct 2020, 22:53

          @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

          @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

          I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

          This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

          Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

          Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

          Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

          You can get the answers from him directly.

          You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

          I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

          My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

          They are not. That’s a market failure.

          L Offline
          L Offline
          Larry
          wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:02 last edited by
          #64

          @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

          @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

          @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

          I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

          This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

          Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

          Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

          Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

          You can get the answers from him directly.

          You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

          I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

          My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

          They are not. That’s a market failure.

          Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

          Jesus H. CRISP.

          X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:03
          • L Larry
            23 Oct 2020, 23:02

            @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

            This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

            Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

            Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

            Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

            You can get the answers from him directly.

            You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

            I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

            My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

            They are not. That’s a market failure.

            Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

            Jesus H. CRISP.

            X Offline
            X Offline
            xenon
            wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:03 last edited by xenon
            #65

            @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

            I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

            This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

            Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

            Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

            Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

            You can get the answers from him directly.

            You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

            I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

            My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

            They are not. That’s a market failure.

            Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

            Jesus H. CRISP.

            The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

            When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

            L 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:12
            • A Offline
              A Offline
              Axtremus
              wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:10 last edited by
              #66

              When (any point in recorded history) and where (anywhere on Earth) is/was healthcare totally devoid of government control?

              L 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:13
              • X xenon
                23 Oct 2020, 23:03

                @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                You can get the answers from him directly.

                You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                They are not. That’s a market failure.

                Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                Jesus H. CRISP.

                The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                L Offline
                L Offline
                Larry
                wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:12 last edited by
                #67

                @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                You can get the answers from him directly.

                You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                They are not. That’s a market failure.

                Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                Jesus H. CRISP.

                The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:15
                • A Axtremus
                  23 Oct 2020, 23:10

                  When (any point in recorded history) and where (anywhere on Earth) is/was healthcare totally devoid of government control?

                  L Offline
                  L Offline
                  Larry
                  wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:13 last edited by
                  #68

                  @Axtremus said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                  When (any point in recorded history) and where (anywhere on Earth) is/was healthcare totally devoid of government control?

                  Would you just shut the fuck up, DAMN I hate trying to deal with morons...

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • L Larry
                    23 Oct 2020, 23:12

                    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                    This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                    Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                    Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                    Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                    You can get the answers from him directly.

                    You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                    I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                    My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                    They are not. That’s a market failure.

                    Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                    Jesus H. CRISP.

                    The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                    When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                    DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                    Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                    X Offline
                    X Offline
                    xenon
                    wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:15 last edited by xenon
                    #69

                    @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                    I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                    This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                    Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                    Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                    Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                    You can get the answers from him directly.

                    You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                    I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                    My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                    They are not. That’s a market failure.

                    Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                    Jesus H. CRISP.

                    The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                    When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                    DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                    Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                    Alright - well, I don't even know why I bother sometimes. I already know Glorious Leader's view on this - and so shall yours be.

                    So - I get it.

                    Obamacare bad! Get rid of it and everything will be hunky dory. State lines! Get rid of state lines!

                    That's the ticket.

                    L 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:17
                    • X xenon
                      23 Oct 2020, 23:15

                      @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                      This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                      Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                      Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                      Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                      You can get the answers from him directly.

                      You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                      I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                      My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                      They are not. That’s a market failure.

                      Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                      Jesus H. CRISP.

                      The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                      When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                      DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                      Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                      Alright - well, I don't even know why I bother sometimes. I already know Glorious Leader's view on this - and so shall yours be.

                      So - I get it.

                      Obamacare bad! Get rid of it and everything will be hunky dory. State lines! Get rid of state lines!

                      That's the ticket.

                      L Offline
                      L Offline
                      Larry
                      wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:17 last edited by
                      #70

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                      I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                      This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                      Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                      Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                      Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                      You can get the answers from him directly.

                      You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                      I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                      My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                      They are not. That’s a market failure.

                      Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                      Jesus H. CRISP.

                      The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                      When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                      DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                      Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                      Alright - well, I don't even know why I bother sometimes. I already know Glorious Leader's view on this - and so shall yours be.

                      So - I get it.

                      No you don't. That's the problem. You are so convinced you're the smartest person in the room that you don't listen.

                      X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:20
                      • L Larry
                        23 Oct 2020, 23:17

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                        This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                        Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                        Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                        Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                        You can get the answers from him directly.

                        You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                        I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                        My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                        They are not. That’s a market failure.

                        Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                        Jesus H. CRISP.

                        The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                        When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                        DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                        Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                        Alright - well, I don't even know why I bother sometimes. I already know Glorious Leader's view on this - and so shall yours be.

                        So - I get it.

                        No you don't. That's the problem. You are so convinced you're the smartest person in the room that you don't listen.

                        X Offline
                        X Offline
                        xenon
                        wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:20 last edited by
                        #71

                        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                        I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                        This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                        Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                        Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                        Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                        You can get the answers from him directly.

                        You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                        I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                        My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                        They are not. That’s a market failure.

                        Once again, you don't understand. There are no market forces controlling a fucking thing. That's the whole point. It can't be a market failure when government is stopping the market from working.

                        Jesus H. CRISP.

                        The existence of Obamacare (what's that like <10% of insurance) - doesn't dismantle the fundamentals of he insurance system that has been essentially the same for decades.

                        When did the US stop having a market based system, in your view?

                        DAMMIT!! it's like talking to a fucking monkey!!

                        Go back and reread my posts, genius. I've already told you.

                        Alright - well, I don't even know why I bother sometimes. I already know Glorious Leader's view on this - and so shall yours be.

                        So - I get it.

                        No you don't. That's the problem. You are so convinced you're the smartest person in the room that you don't listen.

                        I never said anything about being the smartest person in the room.

                        What I said was simple. More old people, more advanced and expensive therapies coming out everyday, old people use those therapies.

                        It's a pretty easy to understand recipe for cost increase. Do you disagree with that?

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        • X xenon
                          23 Oct 2020, 22:53

                          @Loki said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                          @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                          I know one Mass Gen surgeon (through a friend). His rates don't change - but he only takes patients through referrals of doctors he has relationships with.

                          This guy is world renowned, but he doesn't get directly paid more for his services. (he gets paid more for other reasons)

                          Ask you surgeon friend whether he expects to continue to get paid 600k plus a year if the country goes single payer.

                          Ask him also what his income would be if his entire panel where Medicare.

                          Finally ask him where most his income comes from.

                          You can get the answers from him directly.

                          You’re working backwards from the premise that I’m some sort of socialized healthcare advocate.

                          I get great healthcare in the US. Better than Canada (though it was not bad).

                          My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                          They are not. That’s a market failure.

                          C Offline
                          C Offline
                          Copper
                          wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:20 last edited by
                          #72

                          @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                          My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                          They are not. That’s a market failure.

                          The market is just fine.

                          Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                          So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                          X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:20
                          • C Copper
                            23 Oct 2020, 23:20

                            @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                            My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                            They are not. That’s a market failure.

                            The market is just fine.

                            Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                            So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                            X Offline
                            X Offline
                            xenon
                            wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:20 last edited by xenon
                            #73

                            @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                            @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                            My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                            They are not. That’s a market failure.

                            The market is just fine.

                            Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                            So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                            You should go talk to Larry, he says there's no market and thinks you're a moron. He's already explained it.

                            C 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:26
                            • L Offline
                              L Offline
                              Larry
                              wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:22 last edited by
                              #74

                              No, I think YOU are a moron. And the way you have convoluted this thread proves it. You think you're smarter than you actually are.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • C Offline
                                C Offline
                                Copper
                                wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:22 last edited by
                                #75

                                I have been buying my own health insurance in the market for 15 years. I have bought some very cheap plans and very expensive plans.

                                Market forces control costs. They certainly control mine.

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                • X xenon
                                  23 Oct 2020, 23:20

                                  @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                  @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                  My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                                  They are not. That’s a market failure.

                                  The market is just fine.

                                  Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                                  So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                                  You should go talk to Larry, he says there's no market and thinks you're a moron. He's already explained it.

                                  C Offline
                                  C Offline
                                  Copper
                                  wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:26 last edited by
                                  #76

                                  @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                  @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                  @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                  My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                                  They are not. That’s a market failure.

                                  The market is just fine.

                                  Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                                  So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                                  You should go talk to Larry, he says there's no market and thinks you're a moron. He's already explained it.

                                  Go on.

                                  Go ask your friends in HR if there is a market.

                                  Even better tell them you don't want their handouts anymore. You want to participate in the market.

                                  I guess you missed it above when I took the time to answer your question about expensive plans with high quality. Here is one I used: https://www.mdvip.com/

                                  X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:32
                                  • L Offline
                                    L Offline
                                    Larry
                                    wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:28 last edited by
                                    #77

                                    Xenon fails to understand that there is a market AFTER government involvement, which is a different situation then the market that existed BEFORE government involvement.

                                    X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:33
                                    • C Copper
                                      23 Oct 2020, 23:26

                                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                                      They are not. That’s a market failure.

                                      The market is just fine.

                                      Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                                      So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                                      You should go talk to Larry, he says there's no market and thinks you're a moron. He's already explained it.

                                      Go on.

                                      Go ask your friends in HR if there is a market.

                                      Even better tell them you don't want their handouts anymore. You want to participate in the market.

                                      I guess you missed it above when I took the time to answer your question about expensive plans with high quality. Here is one I used: https://www.mdvip.com/

                                      X Offline
                                      X Offline
                                      xenon
                                      wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:32 last edited by xenon
                                      #78

                                      @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      @Copper said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      @xenon said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                      My point is that there’s a mistaken assumption that market forces are somehow controlling cost in this country.

                                      They are not. That’s a market failure.

                                      The market is just fine.

                                      Obamacare is a very small part of the picture. And obamacare users participate in the market.

                                      So does whoever gives you your insurance - go ask them. They will tell you they spend a lot of time watching the market.

                                      You should go talk to Larry, he says there's no market and thinks you're a moron. He's already explained it.

                                      Go on.

                                      Go ask your friends in HR if there is a market.

                                      Even better tell them you don't want their handouts anymore. You want to participate in the market.

                                      I guess you missed it above when I took the time to answer your question about expensive plans with high quality. Here is one I used: https://www.mdvip.com/

                                      Sorry I didn't respond. But if I understood you correctly, you switched networks to follow a doctor who moved to another network.

                                      You're not going to pay more or less within that network for doctors (presumably they're not all of the exact same quality in that network).

                                      And I'm not saying there's not higher quality networks, or that there aren't plans with "better" coverage.

                                      I'm saying - there's very little adjustment of the standard of care across doctors.

                                      Would you agree that there is more treatment we can throw at patients now than 20 years ago? Wouldn't that increase cost? How is that controlled?

                                      Who decides when enough treatment and enough dollars have been spent on a patient? Who is looking at the outcomes / $ spent on specific treatments?

                                      C 1 Reply Last reply 24 Oct 2020, 02:04
                                      • L Larry
                                        23 Oct 2020, 23:28

                                        Xenon fails to understand that there is a market AFTER government involvement, which is a different situation then the market that existed BEFORE government involvement.

                                        X Offline
                                        X Offline
                                        xenon
                                        wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:33 last edited by
                                        #79

                                        @Larry said in Trump to unveil healthcare plan:

                                        Xenon fails to understand that there is a market AFTER government involvement, which is a different situation then the market that existed BEFORE government involvement.

                                        I understood what you said. My question for you was, when did this fundamental shift from before government to after government happen?

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        • L Offline
                                          L Offline
                                          Larry
                                          wrote on 23 Oct 2020, 23:35 last edited by
                                          #80

                                          In the 70s. I already told you thst.

                                          X 1 Reply Last reply 23 Oct 2020, 23:36
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes

                                          70/111

                                          23 Oct 2020, 23:17


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          70 out of 111
                                          • First post
                                            70/111
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Tags
                                          • Popular
                                          • Users
                                          • Groups