UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot

[Mik]

Bet those CEOs aren’t carrying pagers.

That said, he had a pretty good plan. Hard to believe he kept the weapon on him and the IDs. Dumb.

[jon-nyc]

I wonder if we found the motive:

The former classmate said the last time he'd spoken to Mangione was in February 2023, when Mangione mentioned that he had suffered a spine injury.

[jon-nyc]

I wonder if his parents and close friends recognized him in the original photos in the news and chose not to say anything.

[George K]

[George K]

@George-K said in UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot:

There are rumors of Federal Charges.

https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/charging-the-murderer-of-the-unitedhealthcare-ceo/

If I were the United States attorney in my old haunts, the Southern District of New York (SDNY) in Manhattan, I’d be looking to charge the suspect federally.

My default setting is that murder is a state crime and ought to be prosecuted by state authorities. State and municipal prosecutors and cops — here, Bragg and the NYPD — are responsible for the public interest that is most at stake: order and security within the city and borough. They also have the most straightforward criminal statutes — in this instance, state homicide laws — to address this violent street crime with the appropriate degree of severity.

By contrast, federal prosecutors do not have jurisdiction over violent crime, including murder, unless Congress has codified an offense based on some federal interest. The classic federal interest — protection of federal officials from being assassinated while performing their official duties — does not apply to Brian Thompson’s murder. Besides attacks on federal officials and property, the usual federal interest that Congress invokes in the criminal law is interstate commerce.

It would not surprise me, though, if President-elect Trump’s nominees to run the Justice Department, the SDNY, and the FBI are taking a hard look at the Travel Act, an old standby in organized-crime prosecutions codified in Section 1952 of the federal penal code. The Travel Act makes it a crime to, among other things, travel or use facilities in interstate commerce in order to commit a crime of violence, including murder, that furthers some other unlawful activity. If death results, the potential penalty is life imprisonment. (The statute is layered and complicated because Congress was mindful to avoid federalizing every violent street crime.)

If Mangione is the assailant (and to repeat, he has not been charged as of this writing), it would seem simple enough to allege that he traveled in interstate commerce to carry out a murder. The question for federal prosecutors and the FBI would be whether the murder furthered some other unlawful activity — e.g., some organized scheme to extort health insurers to change their practices.

One other advantage the feds have: New York’s doctrine of equitable double jeopardy.

In most states, when the feds and the state authorities both have jurisdiction over a violent crime, they can both prosecute it. In our federalist system, the federal government and the states are both sovereign. Under the dual-sovereignty doctrine, there is no double jeopardy protection from a prosecution by one sovereign after another sovereign has already prosecuted the same defendant for the same crime.

In New York, however, if the federal government brings a case, state law precludes state authorities from prosecuting state offenses arising out of the same criminal transaction (there are some exceptions, but they are narrow and tough for state prosecutors to exploit).

Hence, if the Justice Department were to try to bring a murder case on a Travel Act theory, or something like it, federal prosecutors have to get it right. If they move in to take this case and they lose it in the end, state prosecutors would probably have no recourse — regarding a murder on the streets of Manhattan captured on video, against a suspect who appears to be buried in incriminating evidence.

The feds could keep their powder dry, watch how Bragg handles things, and proceed if he does something outrageous. On the other hand, if they’re going to move, the feds will want to do so now, while they might still have a chance to control the course of the investigation.

Tough call.

[George K]

X account suspended.

And restored.

[Mik]

An Influencer, by the reactions to his act.

[89th]

I see the screws holding his spine together.

[Horace]

He seems to have found a way to exercise his core just the same. And he was trotting along well, after he killed the guy.

[jon-nyc]

My god. A guy I went to high school with just posted this.

[LuFins Dad]

@89th said in UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot:

OMG he lives 3 blocks away from me!

Kidding.

His house, though:

It’s nice, but not exactly what you would expect from a guy heading up one of the largest insurance rackets in the US. I mean, isn’t he supposed to be living large in huge mansion with 4 outdoor pools (and 1 indoor) on 10 acres with a gated entry?

[jon-nyc]

I think that’s the perp’s house.

[LuFins Dad]

Ahhh, @89th had mentioned living close to the CEO. I haven’t had my coffee yet… that’s what you get…

[Mik]

@jon-nyc said in UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot:

I think that’s the perp’s house.

So the perp still lived with M&D.

I wonder if they are glad he's moving out and will not likely be back.

[89th]

@LuFins-Dad said in UnitedHealthcare CEO fatally shot:

Ahhh, @89th had mentioned living close to the CEO. I haven’t had my coffee yet… that’s what you get…

Yeah the CEO actually had 2 houses, was separated from his wife apparently. I found his 2nd house just last night... they are both within a mile of me, although his houses are each like $1.3 million.

But you know what, the house above is $800,000....I think the perp was living with his parents? Not sure.

[George K]

"Which vigilante action is OK?"

[89th]

The 3 faces made at 0:10... they're life WTF planet are you on?

[Mik]

Idiot. How does she get to be a tv commentator?

Oh, wait...never mind. i know.

[jon-nyc]

The manifesto.

[jon-nyc]

One more in the W column for community notes.