Grok vs OpenAI

[jon-nyc]

Would Mohammad fit the modern definition of pedophile? No commentary or excuses, just yes or no.

Grok:
Yes.

OpenAI:
Based on the modern clinical definition of pedophilia—a persistent sexual attraction to prepubescent children (typically under age 11)—the historical records regarding Muhammad’s marriage to Aisha suggest that she was prepubescent at the time of marriage but likely pubescent at consummation.

If the reports that consummation occurred when she was nine are taken at face value, then yes, by today’s definition, this would fit the criteria for pedophilic behavior. However, if she had reached puberty at the time of consummation, then no, it would not meet the strict clinical definition of pedophilia, which requires an attraction to prepubescent children rather than just young adolescents.

[jon-nyc]

While I get ChatGPT’s point, and I think there’s an important distinction between men attracted to prepubescent girls vs developed minors, I don’t know anyone who wouldn’t use the word ‘pedophilia’ for a middle aged man fucking an 11 year old.