SALT and mortgage deductions
-
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 19:15 last edited by
The mortgage interest deduction should be full on eliminated.
-
Yep. Its a relatively modest house too. 2400 sq ft on 1/3 acre lot.
It seems outrageous (and it is), but most people moving here from the city are giving up city income tax and private school tuition in exchange, so its a deal. (property taxes in the city are quite low)
If I lived over the border in CT it would be half for the same house. But the commute to the city would be longer.
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 22:28 last edited by@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
Yep. Its a relatively modest house too. 2400 sq ft on 1/3 acre lot.
About the same as our house; a 2700 sq ft two storey with developed basement and double detached garage on a 150 x 60 ft lot. Mature neighborhood.
-
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 22:34 last edited by Renauda 2 Mar 2021, 22:35
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The mortgage interest deduction should be full on eliminated.
Canada has never had such a deduction on residential properties. We also manage just fine to buy houses and pay out mortgages without too much undue stress in its absence. I wouldn't want such a deduction introduced either.
-
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:16 last edited by
It’s really a bank subsidy.
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here, even credit card and auto. It was a big banking subsidy.
It’s not even a subsidy for homeownership, it’s a subsidy for “home borrowership”.
-
It’s really a bank subsidy.
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here, even credit card and auto. It was a big banking subsidy.
It’s not even a subsidy for homeownership, it’s a subsidy for “home borrowership”.
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:18 last edited by@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here,
All interest?
I remember when all taxes were deductible. I used to keep track of taxes on my utility bills (phone, heat, etc) and claim that deduction.
-
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:26 last edited by@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
Move to Florida.
-
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
Move to Florida.
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:35 last edited by Jolly 2 Mar 2021, 23:36@jolly said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
Move to Florida.
Or Louisiana.
Nice cottage, close to LSU, and your property taxes would be considerably less....
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/498-S-Lakeshore-Dr-Baton-Rouge-LA-70808/66265727_zpid/
-
@jolly said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
Move to Florida.
Or Louisiana.
Nice cottage, close to LSU, and your property taxes would be considerably less....
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/498-S-Lakeshore-Dr-Baton-Rouge-LA-70808/66265727_zpid/
-
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here,
All interest?
I remember when all taxes were deductible. I used to keep track of taxes on my utility bills (phone, heat, etc) and claim that deduction.
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:53 last edited by@george-k said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here,
All interest?
I remember when all taxes were deductible. I used to keep track of taxes on my utility bills (phone, heat, etc) and claim that deduction.
86 tax bill removed deductibility of 'personal interest'
-
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:56 last edited by
time flies
-
wrote on 3 Feb 2021, 23:59 last edited by
From a WaPo piece after the 1986 tax bill. The same law removed local sales taxes also removed personal interest deduction (ex-mortgages).
State and local sales taxes will not be deductible. Income, real-estate and property taxes will be deductible.
Those who take the standard deduction cannot deduct charitable contributions, but itemizers can.
Deductions for interest on non-mortgage loans, such as credit-card debt or auto loans, will be phased out. Sixty-five percent can be deducted in 1987, 40 percent in 1988, 20 percent in 1989, 10 percent in 1990 and none thereafter.
-
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:00 last edited by
It's interesting to read now.
Remember these names?
Flanking the president as he signed the 879-page Tax Reform Act of 1986 were Republican and Democratic lawmakers influential in bringing about its passage -- and a few who worried to the end that the dramatic changes would harm middle-class taxpayers, slow the economy and impair the ability of U.S. companies to compete abroad.
House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Dan Rostenkowski (D-Ill.), the congressional leader who took the measure over its first legislative hurdles, watched intently over Reagan's right shoulder as the president signed the law with 12 pens, one for each letter of his name. Senate Finance Committee Chairman Bob Packwood (R-Ore.), who persuaded his reluctant committee members to resist entrenched opposition, stayed in Oregon to campaign for reelection.
Sen. Bill Bradley (D-N.J.), dubbed by Packwood the "godfather" of tax overhaul, was also in Oregon -- against his will. Bradley, who had been campaigning for Democratic gubernatorial hopeful Neil Goldschmidt, was fogged in at the Portland airport. He and Packwood watched the bill-signing on a special television hook-up at the Portland Marriott and later talked by telephone to Reagan.
-
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:03 last edited by
Of course I remember those names.
I also remember George Will commenting on the new tax law:
Q: So, the new tax law lowers rates, but also eliminates a lot of deductions. What's to prevent congress from raising the rates while keeping the deductions off the table?
Will: Nothing.
-
Of course I remember those names.
I also remember George Will commenting on the new tax law:
Q: So, the new tax law lowers rates, but also eliminates a lot of deductions. What's to prevent congress from raising the rates while keeping the deductions off the table?
Will: Nothing.
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:05 last edited by jon-nyc 2 Apr 2021, 00:05But in the event they lowered rates even more and many deductions crept back in.
-
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:08 last edited by
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
many deductions crept back in
For a schmoe like me, what deductions crept in?
-
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:15 last edited by
For shmoes like you and me the estate tax is the big one. The bar where that kicks in has been raised considerably.
401k kicked in just before then, but has been growing in deductibility and use.
But we've also had a proliferation of tax credits, mostly for low income people but some for people with kids regardless.
-
@jolly said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
Move to Florida.
Or Louisiana.
Nice cottage, close to LSU, and your property taxes would be considerably less....
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/498-S-Lakeshore-Dr-Baton-Rouge-LA-70808/66265727_zpid/
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:50 last edited by@jolly said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jolly said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@lufins-dad said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
The Mortgage Interest Deduction is still there,
It’s sorta there. They cap it at 10k. My property taxes are almost 35k. I have no mortgage, so unless my charitable giving is north of 14k I don’t itemize.
Someone in my neighborhood with a big mortgage would have gotten hit even harder. (They capped that too).
Move to Florida.
Or Louisiana.
Nice cottage, close to LSU, and your property taxes would be considerably less....
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/498-S-Lakeshore-Dr-Baton-Rouge-LA-70808/66265727_zpid/
Piker.
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/11001-Highland-Rd-Baton-Rouge-LA-70810/66335986_zpid/
-
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 00:57 last edited by
@george-k said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
@jolly taxes are $8900???
DaFuq?
I read that as taxes were $1036, the assessed value was $8900...
-
It’s really a bank subsidy.
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here, even credit card and auto. It was a big banking subsidy.
It’s not even a subsidy for homeownership, it’s a subsidy for “home borrowership”.
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 01:53 last edited by@jon-nyc said in SALT and mortgage deductions:
It’s really a bank subsidy.
The older folks here will remember when all interest was deductible here, even credit card and auto. It was a big banking subsidy.
It’s not even a subsidy for homeownership, it’s a subsidy for “home borrowership”.
Never thought of it that way. Makes sense though.
As if the banking sector needs subsidies.
-
wrote on 4 Feb 2021, 02:21 last edited by
Yeah, to really subsidize household formation they could subsidize down payments, for example. Even limit it to the first home purchase. And not waste the subsidy on established households in their second or third home.