What are you reading now?
-
I caved...
This is the audio version with multiple actors portraying the characters. I've only gotten to the "Arrival at Arrakis" part, but so far it's a very good adaptation.
@George-K said in What are you reading now?:
I caved...
This is the audio version with multiple actors portraying the characters. I've only gotten to the "Arrival at Arrakis" part, but so far it's a very good adaptation.
Followup...
I finished it a while ago. This was my third time through the book (2nd time on audio).
It hasn't worn as well as I'd hoped it would.
The early parts of the book, the departure from Caledan, arrival on Arrakis, the world-building and putting all the pieces in play still are amazing. So creative...
The entire middle section, with Paul and Jessica in the desert has way too much mysticism (for a guy like me who likes "hard" SF). There seems to be a lot of "filler" material: much of the Harkonnen stuff is irrelevant and distracting in the middle as well.
The closing of the book seemed rushed. Fast forward years, and now the final confrontation is staged...and just like that, it's done. The final confrontation between Paul and F'yed (the knife fight) is silly, and the resolution of Paul marrying Irulan is contrived.
I think, in retrospect, I was more impressed with the world-building and creativity of ideas (the Spacing Guild, the spice, the Bene Gesseret etc) rather than actual plot. It could have been 60% shorter and told the same story in a more concise way.
Oh, well....
"Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08
The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.
-
"On The Road" is a ... what's the word...touchstone book for the 1960s.
I've never read it.
Worth my time?
@George-K said in What are you reading now?:
"On The Road" is a ... what's the word...touchstone book for the 1960s.
I've never read it.
Worth my time?
It was an influence on me in terms of expectations of my life. Manchild in the Promised Land by Claude Brown was probably greater.
-
Kind of like a documentary book (which I like). It talks about a small town in Pennsylvania USA called Aliquippa. It uses the high school football team to tell the story of the town, which started out as a steel factory town. Kind of sociology study of "middle" USA. The football is just the small center of the story the book tells. Even if you dont know a whole lot about US football, that is okay.
Really good book so far (I am about 60% done). A lot of the things that are discussed (labor/management, race relation, general living, etc.) are the same today as back then.
The more history repeats itself, the more it is the same.
I recommend it.
Reminds me a little of another book I read (actually listeded to) called "Friday Night Light", which used a high school football team to look at a town in Texas. The "Friday Night Light" booked studied the town (mostly) over a one year period, while this book looks at the town over the past 80 or so years.
Good compliments to each other.
-
Kind of like a documentary book (which I like). It talks about a small town in Pennsylvania USA called Aliquippa. It uses the high school football team to tell the story of the town, which started out as a steel factory town. Kind of sociology study of "middle" USA. The football is just the small center of the story the book tells. Even if you dont know a whole lot about US football, that is okay.
Really good book so far (I am about 60% done). A lot of the things that are discussed (labor/management, race relation, general living, etc.) are the same today as back then.
The more history repeats itself, the more it is the same.
I recommend it.
Reminds me a little of another book I read (actually listeded to) called "Friday Night Light", which used a high school football team to look at a town in Texas. The "Friday Night Light" booked studied the town (mostly) over a one year period, while this book looks at the town over the past 80 or so years.
Good compliments to each other.
@taiwan_girl said in What are you reading now?:
a small town in Pennsylvania USA called Aliquippa
Been there, it's a PA suburb. Bet you ten bucks LD and Big AL have been, too.
-
@taiwan_girl said in What are you reading now?:
a small town in Pennsylvania USA called Aliquippa
Been there, it's a PA suburb. Bet you ten bucks LD and Big AL have been, too.
@Aqua-Letifer said in What are you reading now?:
@taiwan_girl said in What are you reading now?:
a small town in Pennsylvania USA called Aliquippa
Been there, it's a PA suburb. Bet you ten bucks LD and Big AL have been, too.
Pittsburgh suburb. I think I drove through it once.
-
"Ragtime...."
A very interesting book. Doctorow's style is unusual, very straightforward, with an occasional diversion into detailed descriptions of an item, behavior, location.
He weaves many historical characters into the narrative (Houdini, Freud, Archduke Ferdinand, Perry, Emma Goldman, Henry Ford), and all of that struck me as being a bit contrived. Yeah, it's clever, but many of the historical characters didn't really add that much to the narrative. It was like - "let's see how clever I can be to bring this guy into the tale."
A fun read, with a story that really doesn't get going until about ⅓ of the way through.
Time Magazine called it one of the 100 greatest books of the 20th century. That may be, but I found it nice, but not overwhelming. It doesn't hold a candle to Gatsby, Slaughterhouse-FIve, Invisible Man, Brave New World or a host of others.
-
@George-K said in What are you reading now?:
I caved...
This is the audio version with multiple actors portraying the characters. I've only gotten to the "Arrival at Arrakis" part, but so far it's a very good adaptation.
Followup...
I finished it a while ago. This was my third time through the book (2nd time on audio).
It hasn't worn as well as I'd hoped it would.
The early parts of the book, the departure from Caledan, arrival on Arrakis, the world-building and putting all the pieces in play still are amazing. So creative...
The entire middle section, with Paul and Jessica in the desert has way too much mysticism (for a guy like me who likes "hard" SF). There seems to be a lot of "filler" material: much of the Harkonnen stuff is irrelevant and distracting in the middle as well.
The closing of the book seemed rushed. Fast forward years, and now the final confrontation is staged...and just like that, it's done. The final confrontation between Paul and F'yed (the knife fight) is silly, and the resolution of Paul marrying Irulan is contrived.
I think, in retrospect, I was more impressed with the world-building and creativity of ideas (the Spacing Guild, the spice, the Bene Gesseret etc) rather than actual plot. It could have been 60% shorter and told the same story in a more concise way.
Oh, well....
@George-K said in What are you reading now?:
@George-K said in What are you reading now?:
I caved...
This is the audio version with multiple actors portraying the characters. I've only gotten to the "Arrival at Arrakis" part, but so far it's a very good adaptation.
Followup...
I finished it a while ago. This was my third time through the book (2nd time on audio).
I got half way through Dune in two days of jury duty (before I ended up on a jury) and never picked the book up again. -
I am reading Nathaniel Philbrick's The Mayflower. Very interesting to learn actual facts behind the myth.
@Kincaid said in What are you reading now?:
I am reading Nathaniel Philbrick's The Mayflower. Very interesting to learn actual facts behind the myth.
Indeed. I enjoyed it as well. If you like Philbrick's work, check out "In the Heart of the Sea." Defoe used a lot of the history of the whaleship Essex for "Moby Dick." I enjoyed it more than "Mayflower."
If you're interested in "fact vs. pop culture" stuff, take a look at Caroline Alexander's objective story of "The Bounty: The True Story of the Mutiny on The Bounty." It's great.
More than two centuries after Master’s Mate Fletcher Christian led a mutiny against Lieutenant William Bligh on a small, armed transport vessel called Bounty, the true story of this enthralling adventure has become obscured by the legend. Combining vivid characterization and deft storytelling, Caroline Alexander shatters the centuries-old myths surrounding this story. She brilliantly shows how, in a desperate attempt to save one man from the gallows and another from ignominy, two powerful families came together and began to create the version of history we know today. The true story of the mutiny on the Bounty is an epic of duty and heroism, pride and power, and the assassination of a brave man’s honor at the dawn of the Romantic age.
-
@George-K said in What are you reading now?:
Off to a rousing start, I might add.
OK - about ⅓ of the way through.
This is good, hard, Sci-Fi.
Set at least 10,000 years BEFORE the events of Dune, it sets up the player, in the personas of the houses - Atreides, Harkonnen, Corrino, etc. It sets up the origin of "The Spice" as well as the origin of the Guild Navigators (at least as far as the ability to move through space at FTL speed). It also gets into the history of the "test" that Paul Atreides has to endure in the opening of "Dune."
("We had to make sure he was human....")
The style is VERY different from Herbert's book(s).
As I said, its hard, HARD, Sci-Fi.
Thoroughly enjoying it, and hoping it doesn't disappoint at the end. If it doesn't, I'll dive into the next of the three prequels.
