Skip to content
  • Categories
  • Recent
  • Tags
  • Popular
  • Users
  • Groups
Skins
  • Light
  • Cerulean
  • Cosmo
  • Flatly
  • Journal
  • Litera
  • Lumen
  • Lux
  • Materia
  • Minty
  • Morph
  • Pulse
  • Sandstone
  • Simplex
  • Sketchy
  • Spacelab
  • United
  • Yeti
  • Zephyr
  • Dark
  • Cyborg
  • Darkly
  • Quartz
  • Slate
  • Solar
  • Superhero
  • Vapor

  • Default (No Skin)
  • No Skin
Collapse

The New Coffee Room

  1. TNCR
  2. General Discussion
  3. Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution

Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Discussion
48 Posts 11 Posters 763 Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • taiwan_girlT taiwan_girl

    It is just crazy the stuff that they are able to do.

    Out of curiosity, how many people think that

    A. There are planets out there with life on them
    B. There are planets out there with intelligent life on them (exclude earth)

    For me, my answer would be

    A. 100%
    B. 85%

    George KG Offline
    George KG Offline
    George K
    wrote on last edited by George K
    #3

    @taiwan_girl said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

    A. There are planets out there with life on them
    B. There are planets out there with intelligent life on them (exclude earth)
    For me, my answer would be
    A. 100%
    B. 85%

    A. 100%
    B. 100%

    It's a really big universe, you know.

    Now, the next obvious question is, even if "B" is 100%, how many of them have the tech/ability to travel the distance to interact with another planet with intelligent life?

    One of my favorite authors, Alastair Reynolds, deals with the Fermi Paradox in a very interesting way, by the way.

    It is just crazy the stuff that they are able to do.

    Wait 100 years. Remember, it was only 102 years ago that man left the surface of the earth on a powered flight.

    "Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08

    The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.

    taiwan_girlT 1 Reply Last reply
    • George KG George K

      @taiwan_girl said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

      A. There are planets out there with life on them
      B. There are planets out there with intelligent life on them (exclude earth)
      For me, my answer would be
      A. 100%
      B. 85%

      A. 100%
      B. 100%

      It's a really big universe, you know.

      Now, the next obvious question is, even if "B" is 100%, how many of them have the tech/ability to travel the distance to interact with another planet with intelligent life?

      One of my favorite authors, Alastair Reynolds, deals with the Fermi Paradox in a very interesting way, by the way.

      It is just crazy the stuff that they are able to do.

      Wait 100 years. Remember, it was only 102 years ago that man left the surface of the earth on a powered flight.

      taiwan_girlT Offline
      taiwan_girlT Offline
      taiwan_girl
      wrote on last edited by
      #4

      @George-K said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

      @taiwan_girl said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

      A. There are planets out there with life on them
      B. There are planets out there with intelligent life on them (exclude earth)
      For me, my answer would be
      A. 100%
      B. 85%

      A. 100%
      B. 100%

      It's a really big universe, you know.

      Now, the next obvious question is, even if "B" is 100%, how many of them have the tech/ability to travel the distance to interact with another planet with intelligent life?

      One of my favorite authors, Alastair Reynolds, deals with the Fermi Paradox in a very interesting way, by the way.

      It is just crazy the stuff that they are able to do.

      Wait 100 years. Remember, it was only 102 years ago that man left the surface of the earth on a powered flight.

      I had to look up Fermi Paradox. As you say, it is a BIG universe. The earth is just a speck in the overall system. Easy to overlook I think. Also, with light years, someone who spied on earth may be seeing us from 1000's or years ago. Not much evidence of intelligent life at that time that would be visible from space.

      Interesting to think about.

      George KG 1 Reply Last reply
      • taiwan_girlT taiwan_girl

        @George-K said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

        @taiwan_girl said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

        A. There are planets out there with life on them
        B. There are planets out there with intelligent life on them (exclude earth)
        For me, my answer would be
        A. 100%
        B. 85%

        A. 100%
        B. 100%

        It's a really big universe, you know.

        Now, the next obvious question is, even if "B" is 100%, how many of them have the tech/ability to travel the distance to interact with another planet with intelligent life?

        One of my favorite authors, Alastair Reynolds, deals with the Fermi Paradox in a very interesting way, by the way.

        It is just crazy the stuff that they are able to do.

        Wait 100 years. Remember, it was only 102 years ago that man left the surface of the earth on a powered flight.

        I had to look up Fermi Paradox. As you say, it is a BIG universe. The earth is just a speck in the overall system. Easy to overlook I think. Also, with light years, someone who spied on earth may be seeing us from 1000's or years ago. Not much evidence of intelligent life at that time that would be visible from space.

        Interesting to think about.

        George KG Offline
        George KG Offline
        George K
        wrote on last edited by
        #5

        @taiwan_girl hard, hard questions.

        The closest star to us is 4 years away, at the speed of light.

        I'm too lazy to look up how close the nearest planet in the "Goldilock's Zone" is to us, but I'd guess it's at least 10s of light years. Let's just say 50 light years...

        So, anything that we did that they could possibly see would take 50 years for them to see. For them to get back to us would be another 50 years.

        100 years for there and back.

        Speed of light is a real bitch. F'ing Einstein.

        "Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08

        The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.

        1 Reply Last reply
        • CopperC Offline
          CopperC Offline
          Copper
          wrote on last edited by
          #6

          We left the keys to airplanes for overnight renters in a lock box.

          The combination was the year the Wright Brothers flew the first powered flight - backward. 3091

          George KG 1 Reply Last reply
          • CopperC Copper

            We left the keys to airplanes for overnight renters in a lock box.

            The combination was the year the Wright Brothers flew the first powered flight - backward. 3091

            George KG Offline
            George KG Offline
            George K
            wrote on last edited by
            #7

            @Copper said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

            We left the keys to airplanes for overnight renters in a lock box.

            The combination was the year the Wright Brothers flew the first powered flight - backward. 3091

            I’ll be right over.

            "Now look here, you Baltic gas passer... " - Mik, 6/14/08

            The saying, "Lite is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap.

            1 Reply Last reply
            • CopperC Offline
              CopperC Offline
              Copper
              wrote on last edited by
              #8

              Subspace communication is the primary form of communication, used by most warp capable species across the galaxy. Subspace communications are dispatched through subspace in excess of warp factor +9.9999, and can thus, travel incredible distances. ( ST reference: The Star Trek Encyclopedia)

              1 Reply Last reply
              • CopperC Offline
                CopperC Offline
                Copper
                wrote on last edited by
                #9

                JWST can see through things - just like Superman

                Link to video

                1 Reply Last reply
                • LarryL Offline
                  LarryL Offline
                  Larry
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #10

                  I often wonder if scientists, or for that matter the "if you question any of this then you are a science denier" crowd, ever take the time to actually listen to themselves....

                  "If you believe that some 'God' just created everything out of nothing in an instant, you're an idiot"
                  "The universe and everything in it was created by a big bang where nothing exploded into everything"....

                  "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"
                  "If we can find even a single solitary one celled thing on another planet it will prove life exists on other planets..."

                  Then there's the notion that we can find life on another planet by looking for pollution.... if the civilization is advanced enough to pollute, it's advanced enough to be looking for life on other planets... yet we've never found even a hint that that has ever happened... alien civilizations are probably advanced well beyond us, able to travel billions of light years by "bending time"..... yet these genius super beings have only ever shown themselves to drunk Bubbas living in trailer parks...... not to mention a civilization so advan ed should have long ago solved the problem of pollution....

                  KlausK Doctor PhibesD NunataxN LarryL 4 Replies Last reply
                  • LarryL Larry

                    I often wonder if scientists, or for that matter the "if you question any of this then you are a science denier" crowd, ever take the time to actually listen to themselves....

                    "If you believe that some 'God' just created everything out of nothing in an instant, you're an idiot"
                    "The universe and everything in it was created by a big bang where nothing exploded into everything"....

                    "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"
                    "If we can find even a single solitary one celled thing on another planet it will prove life exists on other planets..."

                    Then there's the notion that we can find life on another planet by looking for pollution.... if the civilization is advanced enough to pollute, it's advanced enough to be looking for life on other planets... yet we've never found even a hint that that has ever happened... alien civilizations are probably advanced well beyond us, able to travel billions of light years by "bending time"..... yet these genius super beings have only ever shown themselves to drunk Bubbas living in trailer parks...... not to mention a civilization so advan ed should have long ago solved the problem of pollution....

                    KlausK Offline
                    KlausK Offline
                    Klaus
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #11

                    @Larry said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                    "If you believe that some 'God' just created everything out of nothing in an instant, you're an idiot"
                    "The universe and everything in it was created by a big bang where nothing exploded into everything"....

                    "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"
                    "If we can find even a single solitary one celled thing on another planet it will prove life exists on other planets..."

                    You really have no clue whatsoever what science is, do you?

                    Hint: It's not "they are from the other camp, hence I project everything I hate about the other camp onto science".

                    LarryL 1 Reply Last reply
                    • LarryL Larry

                      I often wonder if scientists, or for that matter the "if you question any of this then you are a science denier" crowd, ever take the time to actually listen to themselves....

                      "If you believe that some 'God' just created everything out of nothing in an instant, you're an idiot"
                      "The universe and everything in it was created by a big bang where nothing exploded into everything"....

                      "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"
                      "If we can find even a single solitary one celled thing on another planet it will prove life exists on other planets..."

                      Then there's the notion that we can find life on another planet by looking for pollution.... if the civilization is advanced enough to pollute, it's advanced enough to be looking for life on other planets... yet we've never found even a hint that that has ever happened... alien civilizations are probably advanced well beyond us, able to travel billions of light years by "bending time"..... yet these genius super beings have only ever shown themselves to drunk Bubbas living in trailer parks...... not to mention a civilization so advan ed should have long ago solved the problem of pollution....

                      Doctor PhibesD Online
                      Doctor PhibesD Online
                      Doctor Phibes
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #12

                      @Larry said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                      "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"

                      That's only really science if you the kill the little monkey with either a large hadron collider or some form of high-powered space laser, otherwise it's medicine.

                      I was only joking

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • KlausK Klaus

                        @Larry said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                        "If you believe that some 'God' just created everything out of nothing in an instant, you're an idiot"
                        "The universe and everything in it was created by a big bang where nothing exploded into everything"....

                        "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"
                        "If we can find even a single solitary one celled thing on another planet it will prove life exists on other planets..."

                        You really have no clue whatsoever what science is, do you?

                        Hint: It's not "they are from the other camp, hence I project everything I hate about the other camp onto science".

                        LarryL Offline
                        LarryL Offline
                        Larry
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #13

                        @Klaus said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                        @Larry said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                        "If you believe that some 'God' just created everything out of nothing in an instant, you're an idiot"
                        "The universe and everything in it was created by a big bang where nothing exploded into everything"....

                        "It's ok to kill a baby in the womb because it's not yet life"
                        "If we can find even a single solitary one celled thing on another planet it will prove life exists on other planets..."

                        You really have no clue whatsoever what science is, do you?

                        Hint: It's not "they are from the other camp, hence I project everything I hate about the other camp onto science".

                        Yes, I know exactly what science is. I also know a dickwad when see one, and I pegged you years ago. You are exactly the type of idiot I was addressing.

                        The bit dog barked.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        • KlausK Offline
                          KlausK Offline
                          Klaus
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #14

                          You could make an attempt to be a little more original in your insults. Your lack of creativity in designing good insults is in fact more insulting than the actual insults.

                          LarryL 1 Reply Last reply
                          • Doctor PhibesD Online
                            Doctor PhibesD Online
                            Doctor Phibes
                            wrote on last edited by Doctor Phibes
                            #15

                            Due to the well-documented stupidity of scientists, apparently there's a space telescope that is being developed and designed by non-scientists, since we all know how clever those guys are.

                            Fifteen years in and they're holding 'focus-groups' and 'creativity workshops' to decide on a colour scheme for the mirror.

                            I was only joking

                            RenaudaR 1 Reply Last reply
                            • KlausK Klaus

                              You could make an attempt to be a little more original in your insults. Your lack of creativity in designing good insults is in fact more insulting than the actual insults.

                              LarryL Offline
                              LarryL Offline
                              Larry
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #16

                              @Klaus said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                              You could make an attempt to be a little more original in your insults. Your lack of creativity in designing good insults is in fact more insulting than the actual insults.

                              @Klaus said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                              You could make an attempt to be a little more original in your insults. Your lack of creativity in designing good insults is in fact more insulting than the actual insults.

                              Please, oh wise and sage superior being - tell me which of my examples was wrong. I do believe it was scientists who came up with the big bang theory, wasn't it? I do believe it was scientists who said that finding even a single celled organism on mars would be proof that life exists on mars wasn't it? Are you willing, oh wise one, my I intellectual superior, to admit that it was NOT science that those who support abortion on demand based their claim that it was ok to abort a baby still in the womb because it wasn't yet life?

                              Fuck you, you elitist asshole.

                              KlausK 1 Reply Last reply
                              • LarryL Offline
                                LarryL Offline
                                Larry
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #17

                                At least we now have the answer to my first question of "do the "if you disagree with any of this you are a science denier" crowd e er listen to themselves..,, the answer is no. Klaus has given their standard response - "you are a science denier!!"

                                I defy him to show a single thing I said about denying science.....

                                I just gored his God, and he doesn't like it. What an empty, shallow mind.....

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                • Doctor PhibesD Doctor Phibes

                                  Due to the well-documented stupidity of scientists, apparently there's a space telescope that is being developed and designed by non-scientists, since we all know how clever those guys are.

                                  Fifteen years in and they're holding 'focus-groups' and 'creativity workshops' to decide on a colour scheme for the mirror.

                                  RenaudaR Offline
                                  RenaudaR Offline
                                  Renauda
                                  wrote on last edited by Renauda
                                  #18

                                  @Doctor-Phibes said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                  Due to the well-documented stupidity of scientists, apparently there's a space telescope that is being developed and designed by non-scientists, since we all know how clever those guys are.

                                  Fifteen years in and they're holding 'focus-groups' and 'creativity workshops' to decide on a colour scheme for the mirror.

                                  Those would be MBA’s in consultation with ersatz intellectuals who refer to themselves as social scientists.

                                  Elbows up!

                                  MikM 1 Reply Last reply
                                  • RenaudaR Renauda

                                    @Doctor-Phibes said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                    Due to the well-documented stupidity of scientists, apparently there's a space telescope that is being developed and designed by non-scientists, since we all know how clever those guys are.

                                    Fifteen years in and they're holding 'focus-groups' and 'creativity workshops' to decide on a colour scheme for the mirror.

                                    Those would be MBA’s in consultation with ersatz intellectuals who refer to themselves as social scientists.

                                    MikM Offline
                                    MikM Offline
                                    Mik
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #19

                                    @Renauda said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                    @Doctor-Phibes said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                    Due to the well-documented stupidity of scientists, apparently there's a space telescope that is being developed and designed by non-scientists, since we all know how clever those guys are.

                                    Fifteen years in and they're holding 'focus-groups' and 'creativity workshops' to decide on a colour scheme for the mirror.

                                    Those would be MBA’s in consultation with ersatz intellectuals who refer to themselves as social scientists.

                                    Hari Seldon wannabees.

                                    “I am fond of pigs. Dogs look up to us. Cats look down on us. Pigs treat us as equals.” ~Winston S. Churchill

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    • Doctor PhibesD Online
                                      Doctor PhibesD Online
                                      Doctor Phibes
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #20

                                      How many religious people does it take to build a space telescope?

                                      I look forward to the punchline with enthusiasm.

                                      I was only joking

                                      CopperC JollyJ 2 Replies Last reply
                                      • Doctor PhibesD Doctor Phibes

                                        How many religious people does it take to build a space telescope?

                                        I look forward to the punchline with enthusiasm.

                                        CopperC Offline
                                        CopperC Offline
                                        Copper
                                        wrote on last edited by Copper
                                        #21

                                        @Doctor-Phibes said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                        How many religious people does it take to build a space telescope?

                                        More than 10,000 people worked on the project.

                                        On a project like that you would want about 90% to be devout religious in order to have success. So, maybe 9,000 religious people required and then another 1,000 who could be the second string, emptying trash and mopping floors, making coffee and stuff like that.

                                        Doctor PhibesD 1 Reply Last reply
                                        • CopperC Copper

                                          @Doctor-Phibes said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                          How many religious people does it take to build a space telescope?

                                          More than 10,000 people worked on the project.

                                          On a project like that you would want about 90% to be devout religious in order to have success. So, maybe 9,000 religious people required and then another 1,000 who could be the second string, emptying trash and mopping floors, making coffee and stuff like that.

                                          Doctor PhibesD Online
                                          Doctor PhibesD Online
                                          Doctor Phibes
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #22

                                          @Copper said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                          @Doctor-Phibes said in Webb Telescope might be able to detect other civilizations by their air pollution:

                                          How many religious people does it take to build a space telescope?

                                          More than 10,000 people worked on the project.

                                          On a project like that you would want about 90% to be devout religious in order to have success. So, maybe 9,000 religious people required and then another 1,000 who could be the second string, emptying trash and mopping floors, making coffee and stuff like that.

                                          I'm not sure you've really grasped the concept of 'punchline'.

                                          I was only joking

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Recent
                                          • Tags
                                          • Popular
                                          • Users
                                          • Groups